| Voir le sujet précédent :: Voir le sujet suivant |
| Auteur |
Message |
cooltouch
 Inscrit le: 15 Jan 2009 Messages: 9096 Localisation: Houston, Texas
|
 Posté: Ven Nov 27, 2009 11:19 pm Sujet du message: Test: Tamron and Vivitar Teleconverters |
|
 Posté: Ven Nov 27, 2009 11:19 pm Sujet du message: Test: Tamron and Vivitar Teleconverters |
|
|
cooltouch wrote:
I decided to start my own thread on this topic instead of posting my results in the thread Anu started. He's testing M42 teleconverters, and my results weren't adding to the topic, so I've moved my posts over here.
Anu used a 10-euro note for his initial tests, and since I have one, despite being a guy from Texas, I decided to go ahead and use mine for my tests. I was able to do a reasonably good job at attempting to duplicate the subject that Anu used. The main differences were:
1) I located the note such that it was at, or close to, the minimum focusing distance of the lens and the lens/TC combinations,
2) I ended up cropping and upsizing some of the images so that all show approximately the same subject area. It does not appear that upsizing affected image sharpness.
3) I took the photos under regular incandescent light and I did not try to do any sort of light balance corrections. Thus my photos have a noticeable yellow cast to them.
The camera is a Canon XS (1000D). The lens I used for this comparison is a Tamron SP 90mm f/2.5 Macro -- a superbly sharp optic, I've found. The teleconverters I used were a Tamron SP 1.4X, a Tamron SP 2.0x, and a Vivitar 2x 7-element macro-focusing TC. All shots were taken with the lens wide open, same as Anu.
Also please note: There is a crease in my note close to the right of images, and because of this, the note did not lay flat there, but bulged upward slightly. Thus, most of the images are a bit softer on their right sides. So you will want to compare the left sides of my images for most accurate evaluations.
Canon XS (1000D) with Tamron 90mm @ f/2.5:
Tamron 90mm @ f/2.5 with Tamron 1.4x:
Tamron 90mm @ f/2.5 with Tamron 2x:
Tamron 90mm @ f/2.5 with Vivitar 7-element macro 2x:
Remember to use the left side of my images for evaluation because the right sides are slightly blurry because of the shallow depth of field when shooting wide open. But just to make things a bit easier for you, I've combined the left sides of all four images into one so you can evaluate them side by side. Plus, these four images are all shown at a 100% crop:
As for results, I find very little difference between the Tamron without TC and the Tamron with 1.4x. The images taken with the Tamron 2x and Vivitar 2x are now about equally sharp (after doing a reshoot with the Tamron 2x). Maybe the Vivitar has a slight edge over the Tamron. Both are somewhat less sharp that the Tamron 1.4x. _________________ Michael
My Gear List: http://michaelmcbroom.com/photo/gear.html
My Gallery: http://michaelmcbroom.com/gallery3/index.php/
My Flickr Page: https://www.flickr.com/photos/11308754@N08/albums
My Music: https://soundcloud.com/michaelmcbroom/albums
My Blog: http://michaelmcbroom.com/blogistan/
Dernière modification par cooltouch le Ven Juil 15, 2022 4:36 pm ; modifié 1 fois au total |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
cooltouch
 Inscrit le: 15 Jan 2009 Messages: 9096 Localisation: Houston, Texas
|
 Posté: Ven Nov 27, 2009 11:22 pm Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Ven Nov 27, 2009 11:22 pm Sujet du message: |
|
|
cooltouch wrote:
Okay, I wanted to do some more testing with my Canon FD stuff. I have an FD-EOS converter, plus I own a Vivitar 1.5x and a macro-focusing 2x, identical to the one I have in Nikon mount, whose images I've shown above. Because the results should be the same between the two, I did not use the Vivitar 2x in this latest test.
I'm using the same lens as I used before, a Tamron 90mm f/2.5 macro with the aperture set to f/2.5. Rather than post separate images cropped to fit a computer screen, I have combined three images: the Tamron 90mm without any adapters other than a Nikon F to EOS adapter, the Tamron mounted to the FD-EOS converter only, and then the Tamron mounted to the Vivitar 1.5x FD, which is mounted to the FD-EOS converter. The center and right images were resized downward to match the size of the left image, and then all three images were cropped to 100%.
As the image shows, there is essentially no difference in sharpness between the Tamron with no converters and the Tamron with the FD-EOS converter. I was surprised by this. If anything the center image is a bit sharper than the left image, which suggests that focus might have been slightly off on the left image. There is also no indication of flare with the center image, which I expected, since I usually get flare when I use the FD-EOS converter. The right image -- the Vivitar 1.5x + FD-EOS adapter -- shows some softness. Overall, it is somewhat softer than the Vivitar 2x and Tamron 2x. And in contrast with the Tamron 1.4x, it is noticeably softer.
I would really like to get my hands on a Kiron 1.5x TC for FD because I suspect that it is a much better converter than the Vivitar.
Next, I'll evaluate all of my TCs at infinity, or close to it. _________________ Michael
My Gear List: http://michaelmcbroom.com/photo/gear.html
My Gallery: http://michaelmcbroom.com/gallery3/index.php/
My Flickr Page: https://www.flickr.com/photos/11308754@N08/albums
My Music: https://soundcloud.com/michaelmcbroom/albums
My Blog: http://michaelmcbroom.com/blogistan/ |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
cooltouch
 Inscrit le: 15 Jan 2009 Messages: 9096 Localisation: Houston, Texas
|
 Posté: Ven Nov 27, 2009 11:43 pm Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Ven Nov 27, 2009 11:43 pm Sujet du message: |
|
|
cooltouch wrote:
Evaluating any optic at its closest focus setting is only half the story, so I took my gear outside and chose a subject that is located at infinity -- or close to it, as far as the lens is concerned. I've continued to use the same Tamron f/2.5 lens for this latest evaluation. But this time, I tested all of my TCs plus my FD-EOS converter.
This first image is with the Tamron 90mm f/2.5 macro by itself. Same camera as before, a Canon XS (1000D). ISO 100. The subject I focused on was the brown colored wooden structure behind the fence. Caught the gardeners having lunch. They didn't seem to mind.
The following are all 100% crops
Tamron 90mm by itself:
With the Tamron 1.4x
With the Tamron 2x
With the Vivitar 7-element macro-focusing 2x
Tamron 90mm with the FD-EOS converter by itself:
With the Vivitar 1.5x and FD-EOS converter:
With the Vivitar 2x and FD-EOS converter:
In the last three images, flare is quite evident. This is due primarily to the FD-EOS adapter. However, some flare is shown in all images, some of which is due to the lens being used wide open, and some of which can be blamed on the TCs. Contrast adjustment takes care of most of this, but no contrast adjustments were done. Next time I'll test the TCs with the Tamron 90mm stopped down to at least f/4 -- f/8 would be better.
My conclusions regarding the infinity tests are that all of the TCs performed well in terms of sharpness. Some performed better than others in terms of contrast and flare. Overall, I am reasonably pleased with all of the optics, but if I had to pick just one, based on these tests, it would have to be the Tamron 1.4x Adaptall-II TC. The disadvantage with this one, of course, is that it can only be used with Tamron Adaptall lenses. In light of that, then, the second best, and most useful will be the Vivitar 7-element macro-focusing TC. A very useful adapter because of its focusing helical. _________________ Michael
My Gear List: http://michaelmcbroom.com/photo/gear.html
My Gallery: http://michaelmcbroom.com/gallery3/index.php/
My Flickr Page: https://www.flickr.com/photos/11308754@N08/albums
My Music: https://soundcloud.com/michaelmcbroom/albums
My Blog: http://michaelmcbroom.com/blogistan/ |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
scsambrook
 Inscrit le: 29 Mar 2009 Messages: 2167 Localisation: Glasgow Scotland
Expire: 2011-11-18
|
 Posté: Dim Nov 29, 2009 1:42 pm Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Dim Nov 29, 2009 1:42 pm Sujet du message: |
|
|
scsambrook wrote:
| cooltouch a écrit: |
I would really like to get my hands on a Kiron 1.5x TC for FD because I suspect that it is a much better converter than the Vivitar.
|
Thanks for these pics - really interesting.
Re. the Kiron 1.5x - I used to have one in the late 1980s which I bought to use with my 100mm f2.8 Pentax SMC-M lens - I fancied the idea of a 150mm f4.5 ultra compact telephoto. The results on Kodachrome were sharp enough if you stopped the prime lens down to f8, but the contrast was still far less than the 100mm on its own. I guess these days it would be easy enough to fix that on a digital camera.
I wonder if it's really fair on the converters to make comparisons a full aperture? Maybe the results at one or two stops down might be a lot better? Or maybe you've tried already and didn't find a significant difference. I have to keep reminding myself that digital isn't film.  _________________ Stephen
Equipment: Pentax DSLR for casual shooting, Lumix G1 and Fuji XE-1 for playing with old lenses, and Leica M8 because I still like the optical rangefinder system. |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
cooltouch
 Inscrit le: 15 Jan 2009 Messages: 9096 Localisation: Houston, Texas
|
 Posté: Dim Nov 29, 2009 6:48 pm Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Dim Nov 29, 2009 6:48 pm Sujet du message: |
|
|
cooltouch wrote:
| scsambrook a écrit: |
| I wonder if it's really fair on the converters to make comparisons a full aperture? Maybe the results at one or two stops down might be a lot better? Or maybe you've tried already and didn't find a significant difference. |
I agree with your wondering. Actually, I began this test, shooting the images wide open, because that was what Anu was doing in his thread. Initially the first two posts above were located in his thread, then I removed them and started my own.
I definitely think that the images will improve a lot with the Tamron macro stopped down at least to f/4. So, I plan to go back sometime -- maybe today -- and do the test again, shooting at f/4, f/8, and f/16.
I know the tests using the FD-EOS converter will fare much better because I know from previous use that, once stopped down to f/4, the flare is pretty much gone with that converter. _________________ Michael
My Gear List: http://michaelmcbroom.com/photo/gear.html
My Gallery: http://michaelmcbroom.com/gallery3/index.php/
My Flickr Page: https://www.flickr.com/photos/11308754@N08/albums
My Music: https://soundcloud.com/michaelmcbroom/albums
My Blog: http://michaelmcbroom.com/blogistan/ |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
|
|
|
Vous ne pouvez pas publier de nouveaux sujets dans ce forum Vous ne pouvez pas répondre aux sujets de ce forum Vous ne pouvez pas modifier vos messages dans ce forum Vous ne pouvez pas supprimer vos messages dans ce forum Vous ne pouvez pas voter dans les sondages de ce forum
|