MFlenses - Une nouvelle vie à l’ère numérique
MFLenses 2026

Forum des objectifs à mise au point manuelle

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.
Pleins feux

Emplacement partenaire mis en avant sur la page d’accueil du forum.

Cheapest Fullframe DSLR
Voir le sujet précédent :: Voir le sujet suivant  


Reply

What's the cheapest (new or second hand) fullframe DSLR for use with manual focus lenses?
(Exakta, M42, Canon FD, Nikon F, Olympus OM)
I hear that the EOS 5 mirror has problems with some lenses.
Will 12MP be enough? I mean that 4368×2912 equals 60 linepairs/mm which should be sufficient for most classic lenses right?


Reply

Used Canon 5D or 1DsMk1/2.

I have a 5D, and there are SOME mirror issues but not enough to turn you off the entire camera. 12MP is just fine. Just don't shoot medium format Smile


Dernière modification par pbking le Mer Juin 10, 2015 10:50 pm ; modifié 1 fois au total


Reply

hey t

i was a little skeptical myself about the infamous 5d mirror issues, but i have to say i havent had any problem w any of my lenses. and while i would rather have 14-16mp, i have to tell ya, to paraphrase a famous quote 'once you shoot fullframe you'll find crop factors lame' Embarassed

seriously, i really love the 5d, and i think there is a forum member who is selling it at a really reasonable price. i do think you could get a canon 1ds for a little less, but i really dont think its worth it. if you go 5d i think you will be extremely happy.

as i just bought mine about a month ago, please feel free to ask any questions you like, happy to help if i can.


Reply

The cheapest used FF should be a Kodak, the last 2 models had enough of resolution and they exists in Canon and Nikon mount.
Andreas


Reply

yes, thats true, they may be cheapest, though amazingly not by much, and in my research they had many IQ problems.


Reply

Koji did report a new mirror for 5D not too expensive (~200 USD) so seems best solution now to buy a used 5D and buy an extra mirror. Shave old mirror for MF lenses and keep extra one for that time when you would like to sell your camera.


Reply

When buying a used FF DSLR I tend to prefer the rugged industry standard with good reports, which is obviously Canon, nothing else. I have some professional Canon cameras (VI, 7, P) working great since 50+ years with no service.

I remember that I very interested viewed the product launch of the EOS 5D.

How is the prism finder of the EOS 5D? I mean most of my lenses are faster than the typical kit zooms, but they are focussed MANUALLY. (And I'm used to bright screens of old Spotmatics or Olympus OM)

Now I'm close to buy my first DSLR. I'm quite sure that in 5 years the DSLR market will be dead, except for fullframe/professionals.


Dernière modification par taunusreiter le Mar Jan 05, 2010 10:19 pm ; modifié 1 fois au total


Reply

Hi T....

take a 5D "classic".. its a good working horse and only a few lenses are really problematical.

If you buy one of these great 5D cams on the second hand market with high shutter counts, you can find that one cheap and if the shutter strikes, you can let the Canon Service Point März in Hamburg or Berlin build in a new shutter..

If they build in a new shutter, they have to disassemble the cam complete... so this is the right time to shorten the mirror.
I did have a crash with the mirror/and crashed submirror of my 5 D ... and the guys from "März" in Hamburg did repair the mirror and submirror. I did discuss the shortening of the mirror with them. They are not doing it by themselfs, but there must be a guy, who is doing this for them. They offered me that. But to expensive, so i decided to look further.

After some discussions in the german "DSLR Forum", the member "Nightshot" (Rainer Höhnle, if you want i can give you the contact facts), can do this for you for little money.
He is well known for his "Sensor-Film" cleaning method and has a lot of experience in repairing and servicing of Canon Cams. He also change the AA Filter of the Sensors, a very sensitive thing to do. He is a specialist.

Maybe this is helpful for you.

Just my 2 cents, if i had to find a solution to your question or that would be the way, i would try.

Second.. dont know, which lenses you want to adapt. If this are fast lenses, take the EE-S Screens for best focus and bright ViewFinder..
If you use Lenses slower than f2.8.. leave the original screen in the mirror box.

If you need split focus screens with micorprism collars, then the best but not the cheapest are from Katzeye Optics.. Optibrite.. improved EC-L for Canon 1DX?


Cheers
HENRY


Dernière modification par hinnerker le Mar Jan 05, 2010 9:49 pm ; modifié 5 fois au total


Reply

you may be aware of it, here the lens compatibility list for the 5D:
http://www.panoramaplanet.de/comp/


Reply

hinnerker a écrit:
...take a 5D "classic".. its a good working horse

Yes, and not only a "working horse", it's much more.
The 5D classic is a fascinating cam!
Elegant and rugged at the same time. And 12 MP are really enough, I mean really!

10, 12, 14, 16 ... I couldn't care less, to be honest.

I think it's a bit like with the question asked to Rolls Royce executives: "How many hp does the engine have?"
The answer: "Enough."

And between my 50+ lenses there are only about five that might cause mirror problems with the 5D. That's perfectly alright with me.

I have bought Henry's old 5D and I have absolutely not regretted it so far. Wink


Reply

Wouldn't worry about digital SLRs having 'enough' pixels, esp. the 5D with it's super-low-density sensor (GREAT for handling noise from source, not through software like the new 5Dmk2).

Although I can't wait to get my negatives out of my new RB67...it'll smack the 5D so far into oblivion it's not funny.


Reply

LucisPictor a écrit:

I think it's a bit like with the question asked to Rolls Royce executives: "How many hp does the engine have?"
The answer: "Enough."


LP, mp's are one thing hp's quite another--there are NEVER enough hp's! Laughing


Reply

Attila a écrit:
Koji did report a new mirror for 5D not too expensive (~200 USD) so seems best solution now to buy a used 5D and buy an extra mirror. Shave old mirror for MF lenses and keep extra one for that time when you would like to sell your camera.


this is the BEST OPTION Smile

I can confirm this AFTER some conversions and shaving the mirror by my hands --

tf


Reply

Sony released the A850 to fight for best price with the new bodies. It has the shake reduction built into the body which is great for old manual lenses and 25MP. Its basically the same as the A900 minus the 100% glass pentaprism and 3 fps instead of 5.

K.


Reply

trifox a écrit:
Attila a écrit:
Koji did report a new mirror for 5D not too expensive (~200 USD) so seems best solution now to buy a used 5D and buy an extra mirror. Shave old mirror for MF lenses and keep extra one for that time when you would like to sell your camera.


this is the BEST OPTION Smile

I can confirm this AFTER some conversions and shaving the mirror by my hands --

tf


Well, I'm not sure. By the time you want to sell it, it might not even be worth the $200 the extra mirror costs.

The range of lenses you can use on it is so wide that it really isn't an issue, anyway, unless you have something very special that you want to use.

Among my favourites are the Flek 20mm and 35mm, the Micro-Nikkor 55/3/5, the Biometar 80mm and Summicron 90mm. None of those need any mirror adjustment and anything longer than that won't have a mirror problem, anyway.

Oh, and don't believe any claims about the number of frames shot. There isn't a continuous counter on the 5D, it resets to zero after every 10,000 shots, or you can reset it manually.


Reply

You can compare camera bodies on this website http://www.dxomark.com

I wouldn't worry about sensor size either. As long as it's real pixels and the glass you are using is top notch you can make stunning 70x100 prints from 12+Mpix. Most photogs never print this large --> never need sensor size.

If you plan on using Nikkors the sensible option is either Nikon D700 or Nikon D3. They are still quite expensive but expected to drop quite a lot in 2-4 months of time. I think now a used D700 goes for about EUR 1500-1700 and used D3 about EUR 2300-2500. Local markets, currency exchange ratios etc. apply of course, in Japan and U.S.A. prices are comparatively lower as aftermarket supply is higher.

If you plan on using M42 mount lenses then your best bet is a register-compatible body, like the above mentioned Canons.


Dernière modification par Esox lucius le Lun Jan 25, 2010 10:53 am ; modifié 1 fois au total


Reply

PaulC a écrit:

Well, I'm not sure. By the time you want to sell it, it might not even be worth the $200 the extra mirror costs.


Who cares about resale value of camera bodies. Especially today the cameras very quickly get virtually worthless, so modifying a 5D (out of the warranty period) is not a problem for me.

In fact I'm even thinking about modifying an old Pentax *ist DS to Exakta mount.


Reply

Spotmatic a écrit:
PaulC a écrit:

Well, I'm not sure. By the time you want to sell it, it might not even be worth the $200 the extra mirror costs.


Who cares about resale value of camera bodies. Especially today the cameras very quickly get virtually worthless, so modifying a 5D (out of the warranty period) is not a problem for me.


I meant there is no point in buying a spare mirror to "restore" it later on.


Reply

Spotmatic a écrit:
PaulC a écrit:

Well, I'm not sure. By the time you want to sell it, it might not even be worth the $200 the extra mirror costs.


Who cares about resale value of camera bodies. Especially today the cameras very quickly get virtually worthless..


Well, the 5D has kept its value quite OK. My used 5D is still worth more than my much younger 40D now.


Reply

to help our friend get back OT, if you distill this thread, it appears the best, least expensive option is the 5d, and just dont worry about the mirror issues--if they end up effecting even one lens i would be surprised.


Reply

For M42 lenses, Sony A850 (or A900) is the best choice; no mirror clearance issues at all, built-in image stabilisation, very “film like” colour reproduction and excellent dynamic range (especially in the highlights), and the most affordable current generation full frame when bought new. Also, has an excellent feel inherited from classic Minolta designs, although may take some getting used to if you are not used to Minolta SLRs.


Reply

yes, that may be true about the sony, but the thread was the 'cheapest' ff. i bought my 5d a month ago for just over $1000usd; the sony goes for almost double that...

btw arkku, do you have the sony--i have been interested to see results from that camera, especially as compared to the 5dmkii. sorry to go OT.


Reply

Arkku a écrit:
For M42 lenses, Sony A850 (or A900) is the best choice; no mirror clearance issues at all, built-in image stabilisation, very “film like” colour reproduction and excellent dynamic range (especially in the highlights)


While I agree that the two Sonys are the best choices for the M42s, I feel like I have to make a comment on your DR statement; how much of the total DR is in the shadows and how much in the highlights is only a matter of how one exposes the capture, as you know, so saying that DR is especially good in the highlights is not really proper. I am sure you wanted to say "if one exposes according to cameras metering, then there is plenty of highlight headroom".


Reply

rbelyell a écrit:
yes, that may be true about the sony, but the thread was the 'cheapest' ff. i bought my 5d a month ago for just over $1000usd; the sony goes for almost double that...


Like I said above, it's the most affordable current generation full frame DSLR when bought new. I think I've seen a 1Ds (mark I) even cheaper still… =)

(But, yes, the 5D is still quite readily available and therefore one choice to consider.)

rbelyell a écrit:
btw arkku, do you have the sony--i have been interested to see results from that camera, especially as compared to the 5dmkii.


Yes, I have the A900. Of course, I don't have the 5D mark II for comparison, but based on what I've seen, I prefer the viewfinder, image stabilisation, resolution, low ISO quality, colours, dynamic range, and Minolta-like interface to the 5D mark II, while the latter has better high ISO quality. Of course, there are other reasons, such as my existing equipment (although most lenses could be adapted to Canon, some with mirror clearance issues aside), and my general anti-CaNikon bias due to their lack of innovation compared to brands like Pentax, Olympus, and Sony.


Reply

Anu a écrit:
[qhow much of the total DR is in the shadows and how much in the highlights is only a matter of how one exposes the capture, as you know, so saying that DR is especially good in the highlights is not really proper. I am sure you wanted to say "if one exposes according to cameras metering, then there is plenty of highlight headroom".


Yes, of course you are right in that what is highlight and shadow depends on how the data ends up being interpreted, but I don't really mean “according to the camera's metering”, either, at least in the strict sense, since there does exist some built-in way which it uses to display previews and in-camera histograms (and this appears to be quite closely approximated by the ±0 EC setting of third-party raw converters), and from this position the highlight range is quite impressive compared to some other cameras.