MFlenses - Une nouvelle vie à l’ère numérique
MFLenses 2026

Forum des objectifs à mise au point manuelle

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.
Pleins feux

Emplacement partenaire mis en avant sur la page d’accueil du forum.

Scanner Recommondation
Voir le sujet précédent :: Voir le sujet suivant  


Reply

I am planning to purchase a scanner. I will be scanning 35mm negatives and slides both color and B/W mainly.

Looking for something cost wise (approximately 200USD) and with good IQ.

I have seen the some of the below product names in the forums :

8800f
5600f canon
some Epson V500 ?

So any suggestions?


Reply

I think, it is the question regarding your rating of film/slide photography. For "from time to time" use the 8800 may be ok.

Otherwise I would suggest a better scanner. Look at the film or slide gallery - you will find a lot of pics scanned with different scanners.

Furthermore you can use the search function. Few weeks ago there was a longer discussion here concerning this topic.

Wink


Reply

I'm happy with the Epson. I think that the results will be better with a dedicated 35mm scanner, but it's good enough for me.



Full size version (3346 x 2202)


Reply

Tharos a écrit:
I am planning to purchase a scanner. I will be scanning 35mm negatives and slides both color and B/W mainly.

Looking for something cost wise (approximately 200USD) and with good IQ.

I have seen the some of the below product names in the forums :

8800f
5600f canon
some Epson V500 ?

So any suggestions?


More people interested in scanning would probably be here:-
http://www.hybridphoto.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=6


Reply

I think first you need to decide if you'll ever want to scan 120 film. That's what made me decide on the V700, but if you're only interested in 35mm you have a much wider choice.


Reply

I am happy with V500 , almost all picture here scan with V500.


Reply

I'll echo what Excalibur and Peter wrote. The Hybrid Photo forum is a great please to learn probably more than you ever wanted to know about scanners and scanning. And you really should ask yourself if you foresee any future medium format use, because you'll want to consider a scanner that will do it, if so.

Having said that, there are quite a few scanners around that will do both 35mm and medium format, so you have a pretty decent selection. I own a couple of Epsons -- a 3170 and a 4990, and I've found both the do a reasonably good job with 35mm and an excellent job with medium format. The V500 is essentially the modern equivalent of the 3170 (I bought it about six years ago) and the V700 replaced the 4990. The chief advantage of the V700/4990 over the V500/3170/3200 is the former will scan more slides or negatives at a time and can scan large format, whereas the latter will scan fewer at a time, and will scan 35mm and medium format only.

I've never used the Canon scanners, but I have seen detailed scans from them -- like the 8800 -- and they appear to be equivalent to the Epson as far as image quality goes. I do not recommend the HP scanners. I bought one and returned it because it was such a poor performer.

There is one series of dedicated scanner for 35mm that might be worth considering, available new for about $200US -- the Plustek 7200 series. I have yet to read a review that actually shows any scans, but those reviews I've read have generally been positive.


Reply

I have a Canon 8600F (older version of the 8800F). It scans 135 and 120 film with decent results; I'd say it's good value for the money. For serious use I would consider the Epson V700, but personally I find it way over what I can justify paying.

As a bonus the Canon scanner came with two licenses for Photoshop Elements—one is labeled “Mac” and the other “Windows”, but both serials work on Mac. Meanwhile, PSE itself is a cheap way to run Adobe Camera Raw…


Reply

I want to scan 35mm only.

V500 is more expensive than 8800F (like 100USD more).
8600F not on sale in my place.
V700 much more than my budget
Plustek not on sale here yet but seems promising...

Knowing that I will scan 35mm only, any other options?

So far 5600F seems to be the most budget-wise solution to me but no one mentioned it. How does it compare to 8800F?


Reply

Tharos a écrit:
I want to scan 35mm only.

V500 is more expensive than 8800F (like 100USD more).
8600F not on sale in my place.
V700 much more than my budget
Plustek not on sale here yet but seems promising...

Knowing that I will scan 35mm only, any other options?

So far 5600F seems to be the most budget-wise solution to me but no one mentioned it. How does it compare to 8800F?



My first scanner was/is an Epson 2480 photo for £8 S/H and it gave very good results for over 500 negs until I thought I would get an Epson V750 and it would get into all those shadow areas of a neg etc (well you know the hype)...but it's a law of diminishing returns for your money and have posted identical shots using both scanners and on many shots you can't see the difference on a computer screen.
So my advice would be to pick up a 2480 or later model for peanuts, develope your skill at scanning, and then go on from there.


Reply

Excalibur a écrit:
My first scanner was/is an Epson 2480 photo for £8 S/H and it gave very good results for over 500 negs until I thought I would get an Epson V750 and it would get into all those shadow areas of a neg etc (well you know the hype)...but it's a law of diminishing returns for your money and have posted identical shots using both scanners and on many shots you can't see the difference on a computer screen.
So my advice would be to pick up a 2480 or later model for peanuts, develope your skill at scanning, and then go on from there.


I'll second this. I've read reports from folks who have the Epson 2400 even, and who were quite satisfied with its results. My first scanner with resolution sufficient for scanning film was an Epson 3170 (claimed 3200dpi resoluton), which was the immediate predecessor to the 3200. Either one of these can be found on the used market (try eBay) for cheap. I've seen the 3170 go for as little as $20US. It cost about $200US new six years ago.

As Excalibur mentioned, I was hoping for a big improvement in my images when I bought my 4990 (the V700's immediate predecessor), but the actually improvement over the 3170 was very slight.


Reply

That is some great info you guys gave but now my only concern is the custom clearance for that big scanners Smile

I will check those second hand local first...


Reply

I am down to two options but I can not decide which. Epson is cheaper and in my mind it is like %60 Epson and %40 Canon. Any comments?

Epson V300
Canon 5600F


Reply

Study their film holder , Epson has weak holder for 35mm film.


Reply

Attila, thanks for the tip but errmmm how would I study that? Smile

Let's wait some comment from users (hopefully)...


Reply

It's true, the Epson film holder for 35mm is a bit flimsy, but you can get third party film holders from betterscanning.com. I haven't tried these, but the reports are good.

I found it annoying that the 35mm holder for my Epson 4990, which is otherwise superb, only held 24 unmounted frames, so I bought a spare film holder from Epson (remember to ask for the two retainer frames that hold the strips in place), and when the first 24 are in scanning, I load the remainder in the second holder, ready for placing in the scanner.


Reply

Personally I'd try to find something better than the Epson V300. As I mentioned before, an older 2400, 3170, or 3200 will probably do you just fine.

I've been using Epson film holders for six years. Yes, they're plastic, but if you can manage not to be ham-fisted, and treat them nice, they work just fine.


Reply

I know you're not considering it, but let me jump in here to express my extreme dissatisfaction with the V700.

I bought it because I needed it to scan my 4x5 sheet film.

Well, it turns out, the V700 (and the more expensive "pro" V750) has huge problems dealing with high contrast near the edge of the frame of negatives (apparently not reversal film).

Specifically, let's say you have an area in your frame that will be dense on the negative; like the sky, and it extends to the edge of the frame. The edge will be very high contrast, since the edge would be dark and outside the frame will be clear.

In those cases, frequently, there will appear multiple ghost lines along the edge of the frame. They are most acute with film that turns clear, such as Neopan 100 Acros.

At first I *prayed* it was a defective unit so I had it immediately replaced (I noticed this from the very beginning). The replaced unit showed the exact same problem.

Check out my two images at the bottom here:

http://www.flickr.com/groups/466058@N21/discuss/72157614358392873/



There really isn't a good workaround. Theoretically, if I could "hide" the clear edge of the frame (the only problematic edge is the "outer" edge), but the negative holder for the V700 doesn't have much leeway horizontally, so it's not possible. I could perhaps create a 1mm mask to line the two outer edges of the two columns for 6x6 negatives. Or, like many people do, I could crop out the edge, though sometimes that would mean cropping out nearly 10% of the frame––AND, if I framed the shot carefully to bring the subject dead center (something I frequently do with 6x6 shots), it would mean I'd have to crop out the other edge, too, so that's 20% of the frame going to waste.

Finally, I could try to clone it out in Photoshop. Yeah, like I want to do that with 2, 3, 4, 5 frames per roll of 120 Twisted Evil


I can't believe people put up with this crap from such an expensive piece of equipment, but apparently they do.


Reply

***Well, it turns out, the V700 (and the more expensive "pro" V750) has huge problems dealing with high contrast near the edge of the frame of negatives***

What answer did Epson customer tech/service give?


Reply

@ rawhead

I use this scanner only for my 6x6 medium film with Epson standard software. So far I have no problems with this combo.

Below few sample all scanned with V700.

http://www.foto-bochum.net/Historical-Equipment/Rolleiflex-SL-66/11056713_KPDRQ#773876344_tfMpv

Wink


Reply

I did not find old models of Epson sadly and ebayers do not usually sell these kind of products worlwide.

Any info about 5600F?


Reply

rawhead a écrit:
Well, it turns out, the V700 (and the more expensive "pro" V750) has huge problems dealing with high contrast near the edge of the frame of negatives (apparently not reversal film).

Sorry to hear you're having this problem with the V700. Like Rolf, I've never ever seen it before. I wonder if it could be a calibration error or something to do with the film holder maybe. Are you using the Epson software, and if so what mode?


Reply

I'm using Silver Fast SE, but I doubt the software would make a difference; the lines are present even in Prescan.

I can of course check.


Reply

Rolf a écrit:
@ rawhead

I use this scanner only for my 6x6 medium film with Epson standard software. So far I have no problems with this combo.

Below few sample all scanned with V700.

http://www.foto-bochum.net/Historical-Equipment/Rolleiflex-SL-66/11056713_KPDRQ#773876344_tfMpv

Wink



.....and I have no problems with 6X7 (shot taken about 25 years ago)
http://i304.photobucket.com/albums/nn172/chakrata/chris766.jpg


Reply

Nope, scan software makes no difference. Here's the same frame scanned using Epson Scan in Professional mode (16-bit B&W). Note that the lines are appearing on the other side, because with this scan, I mounted the negative in the left column; thus, the "outer" edge is on the left side of the frame, rather than the right.

Sorry the image is cruddy since I didn't take the time to properly tweak the settings.











What's of note is that the banding don't *always* occur. I could have frames that appear similar in characteristics (sky in the upper half of the frame, darker bottom half) and still not get them. E.g.:










I do not know what the trigger is. Of course, since there are two more images on the strip, it might actually be one of the other ones that is acting as the trigger, not necessarily this frame with the old house.



Hmmm. I'll have to experiment more.