MFlenses - Une nouvelle vie à l’ère numérique
MFLenses 2026

Forum des objectifs à mise au point manuelle

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.
Pleins feux

Emplacement partenaire mis en avant sur la page d’accueil du forum.

Panasonic G1 or Olympus E-520/620?
Voir le sujet précédent :: Voir le sujet suivant  


Reply

At this time, I'm just looking for information. It will be a while before I can afford to buy another DSLR. So I'm curious, which body or system would be better to use with my Canon FD lenses?

I've browsed both the G1 and Oly stickies, and note that both systems will accept adapters for Canon FD. After doing a bit of research, it appears the Oly E-520 is the cheapest of all the current technology μ4/3 DSLRs available, and probably the cheapest also if I were to buy used.

But I am very curious about your opinions, especially if you have had the chance to use both Panasonic and Olympus systems. Unfortunately, I will not be able to afford any of the more expensive DSLRs that either company makes. Mostly I just want a camera with reasonably good features -- say 10+ mp, a decent frame rate (say 3+ fps), and I'd really like to be able to shoot in RAW mode. Also good noise control is important. If I can use my Nikkors on a μ4/3 camera, that's a big plus, but whichever I end up with, I'll have to have infinity focusing of FD lenses as a first priority.


Reply

On Olympus 4/3 you need to change lens mount on each lens to get infinity support. On micro 4/3 like G1 you can use most lenses with a simple adapter including FD lenses with infinity support.


Reply

Oh, well that explains a lot. If I wanted to change the lens mount, I'd just convert to EOS and not spend the money on another camera system.


Reply

G1 has very short register distance this makes it most compatible digital camera system I see one disadvantage only 2x crop factor that is too much for most wide lenses other-ways best MF lens platform what is available today. I will take one also to use my Konica lenses and I would like to discover also Canon FD mount ones too. I can't wait for Samsung NX, basically it will be same camera , but with bigger sensor APS-C this means crop factor will be less also around 1.5


Reply

Hmmm . . . now that Samsung sounds interesting. As I mentioned in my first post, at this point, I'm just gathering information. So maybe by the time the Samsung is available, I'll be able to give it some serious consideration.


Reply

Samsung NX10 is announced today

http://www.dpreview.com/previews/samsungnx10/


Reply

The flange distance for the Samsung NX10 is 25.5mm, so uit should mount Canon FD lenses.


Reply

i think the samsung would be a lot more expensive than the used olly. i love the olly color, always have even in film. the big issue for me in olly vs panny is the olly has in camera IS. if you are concerned about noise, as your 1st post suggested, you will pick up maybe 4 stops with the olly and, while i havent used either camera, i would bet the farm that shooting the olly w mf lenses at 800 will yield better low noise results than the panny at 1600!

if you seriously consider the samsung at that price point (6-700usd), then may i also suggest you look at the olly ep1, which is much smaller, has great low light capability, and has in camera IS, and a new one will probably cost you less than a new samsung. abbazz has one and has put up some beautiful pictures for you to take a look at.


Reply

A quick point about the Samsung - because the crop factor is less, the effective focal length is less = slightly less camera shake when hand holding I guess Smile


Reply

is that true graham? i didnt realize that crop factor effected camera shake, but it makes sense now that i think about it. and for the life of my i couldnt figure out why i gained at least 1 stop advantage from my 5d over my sd14 (crop factor 1.7) and now it makes sense!


Reply

rbelyell a écrit:
is that true graham? i didnt realize that crop factor effected camera shake, but it makes sense now that i think about it. and for the life of my i couldnt figure out why i gained at least 1 stop advantage from my 5d over my sd14 (crop factor 1.7) and now it makes sense!


Yep Smile

If you think about it, handheld, as a minimum, a 135mm lens:

On full frame requires a shutter speed of 1/135th second
On 1.5x crop requires a shutter speed of 1/200th second
On 2 x crop (4/3rds) requires a shutter speed of 1/270th second

Smile


Reply

I can't say I've noticed that at all - it's still a 135mm lens and it's only a rule of thumb/guideline. I can't see it making any difference to camera shake effect what section of the image circle the camera sees.


Reply

Farside a écrit:
I can't say I've noticed that at all - it's still a 135mm lens and it's only a rule of thumb/guideline. I can't see it making any difference to camera shake effect what section of the image circle the camera sees.


well dave, i cant vouch for the technical side, but i can say i personally noticed a big difference in that i gained at least one stop on my 5d over sd14, and that does translate into clearer, less shake effected images!


Reply

rbelyell a écrit:
Farside a écrit:
I can't say I've noticed that at all - it's still a 135mm lens and it's only a rule of thumb/guideline. I can't see it making any difference to camera shake effect what section of the image circle the camera sees.


well dave, i cant vouch for the technical side, but i can say i personally noticed a big difference in that i gained at least one stop on my 5d over sd14, and that does translate into clearer, less shake effected images!

Yes, but comparative weights, weight distribution and ergonomics all play a part. How would you say the SD14 and the 5D stack up that way?

For example, the one and only thing that bugged me slightly about my Canon 10D in the early days of my use of it was the off-vertical and forward shutter button which contributed to shake until I trained my handholding and shutterfinger technique to take it into account.
The K10D shutter button is set slightly flatter and further back, as a result shake is much improved - even without SR turned on.
Harkening back to film cameras, I can think of several examples illustrating the same effect - generally a well-balanced camera suffers from less user shake and especially so those ones that had a bit of heft in the right place. I found the OM-1 was transformed with the winder attached to it; not that it was crap to begin with, but that extra weight and grip improved it tremendously.


Reply

wow dave i wouldnt even think of playing in that pen! Laughing

button placement, dunno-dont notice any difference. weight, yeah, 5d is heavier. shooting style--still stinks!

imho, it really is the crop thing that shrek id'd. it just makes sense, in that simple-linear way i find so attractive! Laughing


Reply

yadisl a écrit:
Samsung NX10 is announced today

http://www.dpreview.com/previews/samsungnx10/


It will be interesting to see how the production release performs. I examined several of the images from the pre-release camera at dpr. Sharpness, contrast and color are decent. But ISO performance is pretty dismal. Noisy at 400 and downright awful at 3200. One can hope that the production release will perform better.

I dunno how important magnification is for an EVF, but with the Live View mode on my Canon DSLR, it is essential for me to insure correct focus. According to the review only the central area in the Samsung's EVF can be magnified, and not by much, and is fairly low resolution. But they do mention that its EVF is big and bright, so maybe magnification isn't all that necessary.


Reply

yeah michael, no offense to anyone, but i think the expectations of/hopes for this camera are way too high...


Reply

Have you looked at the Panasonic Lumix GF1?


Reply

andy youve posted some great results with that camera, as have some other members, and i am very intd in m4/3s generally for a variety of reasons, like form factor, live view, lens versatility. to be honest, the lack of in camera IS is a deal breaker for me, and why i myself have been considering the olly ep2. having just gotten the 5d however, im having such a blast w ff that m4/3 is going to have to wait a while!


Reply

On why crop factor contributing to handheldability in slow speed / tele, I think, it must be the same reason why tele lenses are more prone to camera shake than wide angle lenses in the same speed. The bigger the crop factor, the greater your 'lens magnification' equivalent would be. Just my 2 cents.

By the way I wish other camera manufacturer join the Samsung movement into micro APS-C (mirrorless) digicam with ability to change lenses. Or better, they made it with M42 thread with shorter register distance and high ISO capability of Pentax K-X. That would be fun!


Reply

yadisl a écrit:
On why crop factor contributing to handheldability in slow speed / tele, I think, it must be the same reason why tele lenses are more prone to camera shake than wide angle lenses in the same speed. The bigger the crop factor, the greater your 'lens magnification' equivalent would be. Just my 2 cents.


Old thread alert!! Just to confirm, with my 5D I can now comfortably shoot my 50mm lenses at 1/50 second, wheras before I needed to shoot at 1/80 second as a bare minimum on a crop sensor 40D.

So although the weight will play a part in minimum shutter speed for sharp shots, the effective focal length has a massive bearing in this.