MFlenses - Une nouvelle vie à l’ère numérique
MFLenses 2026

Forum des objectifs à mise au point manuelle

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.
Pleins feux

Emplacement partenaire mis en avant sur la page d’accueil du forum.

Black and White
Voir le sujet précédent :: Voir le sujet suivant  


Reply

Just a quick question...

Is it preferable to use the in camera B&W mode or just post process from colour? Is there a difference?


Reply

like any other type of editing, imho, you have more control of look if you convert yourself. there is a difference even if you just use software auto convert vs camera auto convert because each medium uses a different formula...good to compare yourself to see which you like better, then play around with manual conversion to see if you can develop workflow settings you like better.


Reply

I prefer using the Channel Mixer in PhotoShop, then manually adjusting the Levels--bring the black up to the lowest point in the histogram and bring the white down. Well we can discuss that more in detail Wink

The camera just doesn't give enough punch...it's more grayscale. I like dark darks and bright whites, but that's just me Laughing



Reply

I always use the standard Canon monochrome conversion in the RAW convertor, because I don't like post processing.





Reply

without having done any comparison my thinking is that dedicated software will do a better job, at least have many more options, than in-camera conversion

BWStyler plug in for Photoshop is great!


Reply

Shoot in RAW set camera to B&W , raw will be recorded in color and you can process it with excellent plugins like silver FX pro.Under shooting you can see pictures in B&W it makes better feedback to you about subject selection than if you shoot in color.


Reply

Depends on the mood. As i said before i've done good pictures in both auto B&w mode, and conversion from raw file.

Raw file being definitely better, but again what i do to obtain b&w is quite simple, i use always the 3 same buttons : )

i have no time to waste on post processing either ...


Dernière modification par hexi le Dim Fév 06, 2011 6:55 pm ; modifié 1 fois au total


Reply

kuuan a écrit:
without having done any comparison my thinking is that dedicated software will do a better job, at least have many more options, than in-camera conversion


Definitely, but I hate post processing at a computer screen.


Reply

eeyore_nl a écrit:
kuuan a écrit:
without having done any comparison my thinking is that dedicated software will do a better job, at least have many more options, than in-camera conversion


Definitely, but I hate post processing at a computer screen.


Need to change your mind if you want to have better results, if not , no matter shoot in jpg and set b&w.


Reply

Attila a écrit:

Need to change your mind if you want to have better results, if not , no matter shoot in jpg and set b&w.


The standard Canon processing looks very natural to me. "Monochrome" picture style in the Canon RAW processor.


Reply

The standard Canon conversion is pretty good. I never use it now though; the conversion in ACR. PS & SFX produce better results.


Reply

I did a blog on digital B&W the other day. It might be useful http://fotoblogzone.com/2011/02/05/digital-black-and-white/


Reply

Attila a écrit:
Shoot in RAW set camera to B&W , raw will be recorded in color and you can process it with excellent plugins like silver FX pro.Under shooting you can see pictures in B&W it makes better feedback to you about subject selection than if you shoot in color.


Exactly right. Whatever the JPG setting you use, shooting RAW gives you all the data the sensor has recorded. Those JPG setting are default values that can easily be over-ridden in RAW development.

So, shoot in RAW with B&W filter set to Red or Green for contrast. Chimp the pictures to see if you have the forms and light and textures you want. In RAW development, change the B&W filter to whatever works best, or switch to color and process it as you want.

I often save multiple versions of a shot with various filters and tweaks. All the RAW data is available. USE IT!!


Reply

martinsmith99 a écrit:
The standard Canon conversion is pretty good. I never use it now though; the conversion in ACR. PS & SFX produce better results.


The Canon standard conversion looks natural, which what I like.