MFlenses - Une nouvelle vie à l’ère numérique
MFLenses 2026

Forum des objectifs à mise au point manuelle

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.
Pleins feux

Emplacement partenaire mis en avant sur la page d’accueil du forum.

More 35/1.4, this time is Samyang
Voir le sujet précédent :: Voir le sujet suivant  


Reply

http://dpreview.com/news/1009/10091610samsyng35mm1p4.asp

And that aperture ring is very welcomed. No price info yet, I hope it's 1/5 the price of the Nikon G.


Reply

Finally an affordable 35/1.4 Smile Will for sure be cheaper than Nikkor, Zeiss, Voigtlander or Canon.


Reply

This is good. It will provide photographers on a tight budget, the possibility of a 35/1.4 lens, and it will also put pressure on the big companies to keep the prices of their big 35/1.4s at a reasonable level Wink


Reply

I've been waiting for this lens since the first rumors were out.
I just hope it will not be more expensive than the 1.4/85.
This 1.4/35 is a lens that I seriously consider.


Reply

Orio a écrit:
This is good. It will provide photographers on a tight budget, the possibility of a 35/1.4 lens, and it will also put pressure on the big companies to keep the prices of their big 35/1.4s at a reasonable level Wink


There's no way Canon will reduce price Smile


Reply

Really great news. Let see how well this lens goes against the other 35/1.4.


Reply

Looking forward to some reviews Smile


Reply

aleksanderpolo a écrit:
http://dpreview.com/news/1009/10091610samsyng35mm1p4.asp

And that aperture ring is very welcomed. No price info yet, I hope it's 1/5 the price of the Nikon G.


I guess I am not the only one who finds the price of the Nikon G 35mm f/1.4 ridiculous...


Reply

nkanellopoulos a écrit:
aleksanderpolo a écrit:
http://dpreview.com/news/1009/10091610samsyng35mm1p4.asp

And that aperture ring is very welcomed. No price info yet, I hope it's 1/5 the price of the Nikon G.


I guess I am not the only one who finds the price of the Nikon G 35mm f/1.4 ridiculous...


I haven't seen much outcry of "the price is ridiculous", rather, there are plenty of people defending the Nikon as "Competitive price"

And then people are complaining about the price of Zx 35/1.4... quite amusing


Reply

aleksanderpolo a écrit:

I haven't seen much outcry of "the price is ridiculous", rather, there are plenty of people defending the Nikon as "Competitive price"
And then people are complaining about the price of Zx 35/1.4... quite amusing


But you know, Z doesn't have the all mighty autofocus.... Laughing


Reply

On the Photokina in Cologne I asked on of the Samyang.pl staff for the price: About 400 Euros and it is expected to be January 2011 buyable.

Further I mentioned the bis size of the lens, then he told me that it is not heavy. After my Samyang 14/2.8 with plastic housing I suppose the 35/1.4 has even more plastic. That sounds for me not that good.


Reply

ZoneV a écrit:
On the Photokina in Cologne I asked on of the Samyang.pl staff for the price: About 400 Euros and it is expected to be January 2011 buyable.

Further I mentioned the bis size of the lens, then he told me that it is not heavy. After my Samyang 14/2.8 with plastic housing I suppose the 35/1.4 has even more plastic. That sounds for me not that good.


Well, in order to make a f/1.4 35mm lens that costs 400 Euros, they must save on something. The build is the most likely target. Better that, than cheap glass, anwyay. People who buys a 400 Eur lens are aware that they need to treat carefully their lens more than what a 1500 Eur all metal lens will need. It's part of the trade-off. The same happens with cameras, with my 5Ds I know that I need to be more careful with weather conditions than if I had a 1D series camera.


Reply

Yeah, that is clear.
But after some problems with my Samyang 14mm/2.8 I think about not going for the Samyang 35/1.4 but for the Canon FD 24/1.4 or old Zeiss 35/1.4.
I do not like to handle my most used lenses like a baby - I treat them more like a hammer Smile


Reply

some samples:
http://www.samyang.pl/art,2,nowosci

samples are from nikon D7000, so it's not FX but anyway, looks promising


Reply

http://shashinki.com/shop/samyang-35mm-lens-pentax-mount-p-6869.html?currency=USD


Reply

Sample images look good!
Some CA but the Distagon is not immune either.
Surely a good resource for those who can not afford to buy a Distagon now or were not as smart as I've been to buy Contax Distagons at the time when they costed 350-400 Euros Wink Twisted Evil sorry! Razz Rolling Eyes


Reply

To be honest, I would not like to spend that much money on a lens that I have never had in my hands.
Built is very important for me and even if I got a lens with a great performance, if the body quality and "feel" is not first class, I would really regret the purchase!

In this case I would rather do without f/1.4 and go with a Nikkor 2/35 or buy a used Nikkor 1.4/35 for the same money as the Samyang.

But if built quality is good, this can be an amazing lens.
So, I guess I definitely wait until it is offered by a German vendor, so that I have a chance to return it (if bought online).


Reply

LucisPictor a écrit:
To be honest, I would not like to spend that much money on a lens that I have never had in my hands.
Built is very important for me and even if I got a lens with a great performance, if the body quality and "feel" is not first class, I would really regret the purchase!...


Me too. I think a lot of us here are probably spoiled by the quality of manual Zeiss, Leica, et all. But hey, this Samyang has the Leica font for the 35mm on the side, can't be all bad, ha.

Always glad to see competition in the market place, but I think if anything, this company Samyang is giving Sigma sleepless nights more than Zeiss.


K.


Reply

As the Samayang 85mm f/1.4 turned out beyond anyones expectations I cannot wait to buy this lens. I have been very impressed with the optical quality of their lenses so far. Also the build quality on the 85mm is much better than you would expect for it's price tag. If this gets better result than the Nikon at f/1.4 it's as good as bought Smile


Reply

thePiRaTE!! a écrit:
... Samyang is giving Sigma sleepless nights more than Zeiss.

True!


Reply

thePiRaTE!! a écrit:
LucisPictor a écrit:
To be honest, I would not like to spend that much money on a lens that I have never had in my hands.
Built is very important for me and even if I got a lens with a great performance, if the body quality and "feel" is not first class, I would really regret the purchase!...


Me too. I think a lot of us here are probably spoiled by the quality of manual Zeiss, Leica, et all. But hey, this Samyang has the Leica font for the 35mm on the side, can't be all bad, ha.

Always glad to see competition in the market place, but I think if anything, this company Samyang is giving Sigma sleepless nights more than Zeiss.


K.


"But hey, this Samyang has the Leica font for the 35mm on the side, can't be all bad, ha." -> Laughing only the "35" though

Anybody here test the 35/1.4 Distagon with the 35/1.4 EF-L?

I wanted to do only B&W this year but i'm so not happy with 50mm for what I want to do ... I wanted to wait for the new Distagon 35/1.4 but am running outta patience.

So - Distagon 35/1.4 or Canon 35/1.4L? Any inputs? They're not too far away from a price perspective and the canon lens is a newer design but which one performs better? AF is good to have but is not a deal maker/breaker.


Reply

Hari a écrit:

So - Distagon 35/1.4 or Canon 35/1.4L? Any inputs? They're not too far away from a price perspective and the canon lens is a newer design but which one performs better? AF is good to have but is not a deal maker/breaker.


Today's top-of-the-line lenses from Canon, Nikon, Pentax must all be excellent lenses. The competition is tough and no manufacturer would survive with less than excellent offerings when the price tag goes above the 1000 $ or € figure.

The Distagon 1.4/35 is a tried-and-true design from the early 70s. The father was a genius (Erhard Glatzel). The lens itself -if I remember correctly- was the first lens ever to feature a so called "floating element" to optimize performance at all focus distances. And it features also an aspherical lens, which at the time was outrageously expensive to produce.

Today, all these features come almost as standard, even on affordable lenses like the Samyang 1.4/35. Hey, 40 years don't pass in vain.
Of course, having those features, and implement them optimally (for quality of materials, for precision of build, for ruggedness and reliability of structure), are different things, which remain to be seen and probably cna be judged only after extensive use under all lighting and weather conditions.

So which performs better? Better is a ugly word. It can be meant and twisted in almost any direction.
I would rather say that all the lenses mentioned are guaranteed to be more than enough performers for the needs of the good average photographer. Saying which is better is a further step and largely subjective, because it depends also on what one values more or less in a lens.

For instance, there is people who gets mad when seeing a trace of chromatic aberration in the pictures. Those people are most likely to appreciate the most recent lenses, because they are designed for the digital medium (which is much more unforgiving) and because the materials and technology needed to control CA in lenses are more advanced and affordable today than they were 40 years ago.

There is people who want bokeh highlights that are perfectly neutral and smooth. These people again are likely to like more the newest Japanese lenses from Canon and Pentax than the older German designs like the Distagon.

There is people who value much the flare resistance in a f/1.4 lens and it's ability to be used in backlight and other difficult light conditions without much flares and keeping good contrast; these people will prefer the T* coating of the Zeiss lenses for sure.

There are a lot of factors. None of the mentioned lenses are going to exhibit terrible shortcomings or problems - they would have not been commercialized otherwise. So any choice is safe. To get the "extra step" is a matter of taste and there is only one thing to do which is to browse galleries of photos taken with the lenses and see for yourself.
In my experience, more often than not, when somebody gave me a comparative advice of two different lenses, after having made my personal hands-on experience I ended up disagreeing in part or sometimes in whole - this because I am a different photographer than you are and he is a different photographer than you and me and so on.
I usually get a much better idea by browsing the galleries and judging by myself on the results that I see.

For sure the lenses are all different in the optical scheme. I could not find the scheme of the Canon lens. The schemes of the Contax, Z, and Samyang lenses show significant differences which obviously must impact somehow the performance by giving these lenses their own different "fingerprint":

Contax Distagon 1.4/35 (Glatzel's original, from Zeiss PDF):


New Z Distagon 1.4/35 (from Zeiss brochure):


Samyang 1.4/35 (from Photorumours.com website):


Reply

Orio a écrit:
Hari a écrit:

So - Distagon 35/1.4 or Canon 35/1.4L? Any inputs? They're not too far away from a price perspective and the canon lens is a newer design but which one performs better? AF is good to have but is not a deal maker/breaker.


Today's top-of-the-line lenses from Canon, Nikon, Pentax must all be excellent lenses. The competition is tough and no manufacturer would survive with less than excellent offerings when the price tag goes above the 1000 $ or € figure.

The Distagon 1.4/35 is a tried-and-true design from the early 70s. The father was a genius (Erhard Glatzel). The lens itself -if I remember correctly- was the first lens ever to feature a so called "floating element" to optimize performance at all focus distances. And it features also an aspherical lens, which at the time was outrageously expensive to produce.

Today, all these features come almost as standard, even on affordable lenses like the Samyang 1.4/35. Hey, 40 years don't pass in vain.
Of course, having those features, and implement them optimally (for quality of materials, for precision of build, for ruggedness and reliability of structure), are different things, which remain to be seen and probably cna be judged only after extensive use under all lighting and weather conditions.

So which performs better? Better is a ugly word. It can be meant and twisted in almost any direction.
I would rather say that all the lenses mentioned are guaranteed to be more than enough performers for the needs of the good average photographer. Saying which is better is a further step and largely subjective, because it depends also on what one values more or less in a lens.

For instance, there is people who gets mad when seeing a trace of chromatic aberration in the pictures. Those people are most likely to appreciate the most recent lenses, because they are designed for the digital medium (which is much more unforgiving) and because the materials and technology needed to control CA in lenses are more advanced and affordable today than they were 40 years ago.

There is people who want bokeh highlights that are perfectly neutral and smooth. These people again are likely to like more the newest Japanese lenses from Canon and Pentax than the older German designs like the Distagon.

There is people who value much the flare resistance in a f/1.4 lens and it's ability to be used in backlight and other difficult light conditions without much flares and keeping good contrast; these people will prefer the T* coating of the Zeiss lenses for sure.

There are a lot of factors. None of the mentioned lenses are going to exhibit terrible shortcomings or problems - they would have not been commercialized otherwise. So any choice is safe. To get the "extra step" is a matter of taste and there is only one thing to do which is to browse galleries of photos taken with the lenses and see for yourself.
In my experience, more often than not, when somebody gave me a comparative advice of two different lenses, after having made my personal hands-on experience I ended up disagreeing in part or sometimes in whole - this because I am a different photographer than you are and he is a different photographer than you and me and so on.
I usually get a much better idea by browsing the galleries and judging by myself on the results that I see.

For sure the lenses are all different in the optical scheme. I could not find the scheme of the Canon lens. The schemes of the Contax, Z, and Samyang lenses show significant differences which obviously must impact somehow the performance by giving these lenses their own different "fingerprint":

Contax Distagon 1.4/35 (Glatzel's original, from Zeiss PDF):


New Z Distagon 1.4/35 (from Zeiss brochure):


Samyang 1.4/35 (from Photorumours.com website):


Thanks for the thorough 360° view, Orio! Your kind help is much appreciated!

I think i'll go with the 35 1.4 L for the moment and get the new Distagon when it comes out - I have my tried and trusted Mir24 till I get the 35 1.4L Very Happy


Reply

more samyang samples
this time from: http://lenstip.com/1897-news-Samyang_35_mm_f_1.4_AS_UMC_-_sample_shots.html

p.s. with 0 level sharpening jpeg-s from D3x, i think looks good
and it's around 400euro

p.s. let's wait for "david and goliath" fight SAMMYvsZEISSZILLA


Reply

Ouch, these new samples are a let-down for me. Even the stopped down photos appear very soft. Sharpening would improve them, but a good lens should be sharper than this from f/4 onwards, even at zero sharpening level. f/4 is soft, f/5.6 is soft, f/8 is soft. Ok, people who buy this lens would mostly use it wide open. But still...