MFlenses - Une nouvelle vie à l’ère numérique
MFLenses 2026

Forum des objectifs à mise au point manuelle

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.
Pleins feux

Emplacement partenaire mis en avant sur la page d’accueil du forum.

New Nikon Standard lens - AF-S NIKKOR 50mm f/1.8G
Voir le sujet précédent :: Voir le sujet suivant  


Reply

They revise the design of the 1.8/50D with a aspherical lens element.

http://imaging.nikon.com/lineup/lens/singlefocal/normal/af-s_50mmf_18g/index.htm


Reply

The aspherical trend continues...
The problem is that aspherical glass elements are very difficult and very expensive to produce, so manufacturers today use polymers instead of glass to make these aspherical elements (and other elements too especially in the low section of the market). As a result of using polymers instead of high quality, hard highly refractive glass, the images that come out of these AF lenses are flat and dull. I have seen the lifeless samples of this lens and I think it must be the most insipid 50mm Nikkor ever. Which is a shame considering the noble tradition of the 50mm focal lenght in the Nikkor catalogue.


Reply

Orio a écrit:
The aspherical trend continues...
The problem is that aspherical glass elements are very difficult and very expensive to produce, so manufacturers today use polymers instead of glass to make these aspherical elements (and other elements too especially in the low section of the market). As a result of using polymers instead of high quality, hard highly refractive glass, the images that come out of these AF lenses are flat and dull. I have seen the lifeless samples of this lens and I think it must be the most insipid 50mm Nikkor ever. Which is a shame considering the noble tradition of the 50mm focal lenght in the Nikkor catalogue.

To meet the demand for these 'cheap' standard lens, the tread of using polymer elements on low end lenses seems inevitable.


Reply

I think I´ll resist to have the SWM instead of lovely rendering of my Zuiko 50/1,8 Laughing


Reply

Seems announcement was premature?

patrickh


Reply

patrickh a écrit:
Seems announcement was premature?

patrickh

I think so. Someone have save the infos on above page.
http://nikonrumors.com/2011/04/13/confusion-new-af-s-nikkor-50mm-f1-8g-lens.aspx

and Kenrockwell
http://kenrockwell.com/nikon/50mm-f18-g.htm


Reply

Orio a écrit:
As a result of using polymers instead of high quality, hard highly refractive glass, the images that come out of these AF lenses are flat and dull.


Optical polymers are no worse than glass in their optical properties - depending on the application they may even be better. The thing to be concerned about with them is aging - one out of two "plastics" zooms I own is already fogged (in the material) after a mere eight years.

I rather suspect the aspheric designs themselves to be the guilty culprit in many "dull" lenses - aspherics first of all allow for better error control with fewer elements. That tends to mean that lenses are pretty precisely calculated to be as good as the budget allows, evenly across properties - which leads to low to mid price lenses that are mediocre on every count, while the traditional predecessor usually had less uniform characteristics.


Dernière modification par Sevo le Ven Avr 15, 2011 8:52 am ; modifié 1 fois au total


Reply

Sevo a écrit:

I rather suspect the aspheric designs themselves to be the guilty culprit in many "dull" lenses


Well, the Distagon 1.4/35 Contax has an aspherical element, but it's the farthest thing from dull that I can think of - I suspect that the fact that the aspherical element is made of very special glass (very hard, and a real curse to work, according to reports) it's anything but irrelevant...


Reply

I am sure it will sell millions because of affordability, but to me this G-series Nikkor 50/1.8 AF-S is just as interesting as the D-series AF, Ai-S and Ai 50/1.8 lenses: not really, if at all. Dirt cheap but doesn't see much use because the faster fifties are more useable and better in the areas which matter.


Reply

Orio a écrit:

Well, the Distagon 1.4/35 Contax has an aspherical element, but it's the farthest thing from dull that I can think of


But it is anything but cheap...


Reply

Sevo a écrit:
Orio a écrit:

Well, the Distagon 1.4/35 Contax has an aspherical element, but it's the farthest thing from dull that I can think of


But it is anything but cheap...


But we were not talking about the price...


Reply

Orio a écrit:
The aspherical trend continues...
The problem is that aspherical glass elements are very difficult and very expensive to produce, so manufacturers today use polymers instead of glass to make these aspherical elements (and other elements too especially in the low section of the market).

I think that all the current higher end lenses that use aspherics will most probably use molded elements. In the Zeiss article about bokeh and DOF it's explained why aspherical lenses tend to display and "onion ring" or spiral pattern in the bokeh:
Citation:
If you look at this picture very closely, you can see another interesting effect – all the defocused spot images contain a circular structure. It is possible to recognise from this that the lens has an aspherical surface as these surfaces are often not as smooth as a conventionally polished lens. Particularly in the case of lenses which are manufactured by pressing hot liquid glass it is possible to recognise the traces of the turning process with which the mould was manufactured.
It is possible to combine rotational and pivotal movements when polishing spherical surfaces because the curvature of the surface is the same everywhere; in this case no traces are left. In the case of aspherical surfaces the curvature is variable and therefore demands other processing techniques. Residual unevenness of these surfaces becomes visible if a very small light source is reproduced very much out of focus.
(from page 32)

A (pretty extreme) example of the onion rings of the Rollei Distagon 35/1.4: http://peltarion.eu/img/zeiss/rz35-236.jpg

Regarding the new Nikon 50/1.8G, it's (calculated) MTF looks not bad at all, so I wouldn't expect dull images from it: http://diglloyd.com/blog/2011/20110427_2-BHPhotoHours.html


Reply

Nikkor AF-S 50mm f/1.8G samples using the D7000

https://picasaweb.google.com/Witkovsky/2011_05_20TestNikonD7000AFS50mmF18G#

Edit - some more using the D3x ...

http://photozone.smugmug.com/Reviews/afs5018gd3x/17263035_v48cRr#1310730935_Ts7Gpfq


Reply

@sichko: Thanks. It looks pretty good, but very well behaved so in that sense I'd agree that to some extent it's a bit dull compared to what a Zeiss lens can give (i.e. a Zeiss may have more vignetting and field curvature, but will "pop" more, generally).