MFlenses - Une nouvelle vie à l’ère numérique
MFLenses 2026

Forum des objectifs à mise au point manuelle

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.
Pleins feux

Emplacement partenaire mis en avant sur la page d’accueil du forum.

Short Tele lens comparison on NEX-3 (Part 1 - Close-ups)
Voir le sujet précédent :: Voir le sujet suivant  


Reply

Klaus was so nice to send me a copy of the Carl Zeiss Tevidon 2.8/70 in c-mount (Thanks, Klaus! The lens will travel back to you soon!), in order to check if it covers the APS-sensor of the NEX. So I decided to perform a little shoot-out of some nice short tele lenses.

Those were the contestants:


From the left:

* Carl Zeiss Tevidon 2.8/70 (c-mount)
* Leica Elmar 4/90 (M39LTM)
* Nikkor-H 1.8/85 (F mount)
* Schneider-Kreuznach Tele-Xenar 3.8/75 (Robot mount)
* Steinheil Culminar 2.8/85 VL (M42)

Nikkor-H 1.8/85 @ f/2.8 (stopped a little more than one stop):

I publish this comparision in the "oversized gallery" so that I can show bigger images.

I shot frames wide open and at f/5.6 (and with the Nikkor at f/2.8, because it is such a fast lens wide open).

Here are the first results (the full frame, wide open):

Carl Zeiss Tevidon 2.8/70


Leica Elmar 4/90


Nikkor-H 1.8/85

Nikkor-H 1.8/85@ f/2.8


Schneider-Kreuznach Tele-Xenar 3.8/75


Steinheil Culminar 2.8/85 VL


Well, there is not much difference, but the 100% crop show more:

Carl Zeiss Tevidon 2.8/70


Leica Elmar 4/90


Nikkor-H 1.8/85

Nikkor-H 1.8/85@ f/2.8


Schneider-Kreuznach Tele-Xenar 3.8/75


Steinheil Culminar 2.8/85 VL


The shots at f/5.6 are all very good. There is no reall point in showing them here.

Next part will be a bokeh comparison...


Dernière modification par LucisPictor le Mar Mai 24, 2011 3:04 pm ; modifié 1 fois au total


Reply

My sharpness ranking:

1. Schneider-Kreuznach Tele-Xenar 3.8/75
2. Carl Zeiss Tevidon 2.8/70 (very close to #1)
3. Nikkor-H 1.8/85
4. Leica Elmar 4/90
5. Steinheil Culminar 2.8/85 VL (with considerable distance!)

The Steinheil with its "glow" can be used as an effect lens, really, rather than as a sharp close up. It produces fantastic portraits!


Reply

I agree with the ranking of the Schneider-Kreuznach. That particular
image simply popped up as the superior overall quality of image.


Reply

SK Tele-Xenar really stands out from others, but it can be partly due to deeper DOF.


Reply

BRunner a écrit:
SK Tele-Xenar really stands out from others, but it can be partly due to deeper DOF.


Yes, you may be right. I hadn't noticed at first. Cool


Reply

It's the Xenar for me too, I take on board the DOF comment but even so, it seems to separate the stamens (?) of the flower with much greater clarity than the rest?

Doug


Reply

The 3D quality of the Schneider Tele-Xenar is impressive. Superbe micro-contrast.