MFlenses - Une nouvelle vie à l’ère numérique
MFLenses 2026

Forum des objectifs à mise au point manuelle

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.
Pleins feux

Emplacement partenaire mis en avant sur la page d’accueil du forum.

Sharp film scanners
Voir le sujet précédent :: Voir le sujet suivant  


Reply

Had a demo this morning of an Epson V500 and Plustek 7400. I was shocked at how unsharp they both were compared to a 10x8" enlargement from the same negative. Both the scans lacked sharpness and detail present in the negative.

Just how much does one have to spend on a scanner to get a sharp scan? My budget is tiny at about 200 GBP (at a stretch).


Reply

GrahamNR17 a écrit:
Had a demo this morning of an Epson V500 and Plustek 7400. I was shocked at how unsharp they both were compared to a 10x8" enlargement from the same negative. Both the scans lacked sharpness and detail present in the negative.

Just how much does one have to spend on a scanner to get a sharp scan? My budget is tiny at about 200 GBP (at a stretch).


There is about 20mp of detail on a 35mm neg, but getting it off cheaply is the problem (drum scanners are old but the best you will get now) and digital is overtaking film because no one will spend the money to produce a VG scanner at a reasonable price, so all you can do with Epson scanners is to scan at say 2400-4800dpi and sharpen in Photoshop.


Reply

You have here a very good research instrument :
http://www.filmscanner.info/en/FilmscannerTestberichte.html
I would suggest a Minolta Dimage Scan Elite II , or , if you stretch a little , the 5400 . I use the Dimage III but it hasn't ICE and have a lot manual correct PP
CanoScan FS4000US and the Nikon Coolscan 4000 and IV ED could be options , if you find in the budget.


Reply

Surprise! ;( Digital is pretty good, but analog enlargements are still better, imho.

Flatbed scan of 35mm film is better than standard scan from film processing service, not as good as drum scan, but for medium format film (120/220) results are pretty good(!), however analog enlargement is sooo much better...

Most scans can be sharpened/unsharpened quite a bit in my experience, more than images from camera.

'Scans' using dSLR with bellows and enlarger lens are pretty good, getting better with sensor advances; more dmax there than scanner. There's anther Topic here someplace showing Jesito's rig using Nex...here it is: http://forum.mflenses.com/film-digitization-using-dslr-advice-needed-t45407.html#1190981


Reply

Hi, there. I second Excalibur analysis, the film scanner situation looks pretty depressing either economically and technically. The V500 seems to be the closest match with your budget. I own one of those and, yes, the files right out of the scanner need badly a good dose of USM. Scanning right on the glass, i.e. without the supplied holder (quite flimsy IMO), seems to improve a bit in certain cases but I can't tell for sure without testing further. Lurking at the old posts I noticed your topic about scanners and Linux and I can tell you the V500 runs under this platform albeit with some limitations ( No ICE dust removal with sane + iscan ). I had quite of a trouble to set it up but in the succeeded though I'm not completely satisfied with the output comparing with Epson scan under XP, The pictures in some cases just look grainier for some reason. I've reason to believe that Vuescan might perform a bit better. For something more money there is the V600, but I don't know about it. The big novelty is from Reflecta which marketed
their new medium format capable film scanner, but at 1900€ is out of my reach .


Reply

visualopsins a écrit:
Surprise! ;( Digital is pretty good, but analog enlargements are still better, imho.

Very true Very Happy, that's the reason I would be very reluctant to give up the traditional darkroom.


Reply

Strange that you find the Plustek not sharp: I had a 7400 (or 7300?) and found it really sharp, especially compared to the Epson 4490 (the V500 ancestor) which I had at the same time.

The Plustek dynamic range cannot rival that of more expensive scanners, but it's ok for non professional use.

Here is a sample image scanned with the plustek



a 100% crop straight out of vuescan, no sharpening


with some light sharpening (1.5/1/3 in gimp(


and the same negative scanned with the 4490, 100% crop


and a Minolta ScanDual II


BTW if your pc can accept a SCSI card, I'd look for one of the old 35mm SCSI only scanners, they are ultra cheap and pretty good. I had a Canoscan 2700F which is worth about 40€ now and is not worse than the ones above.


Reply

unfortunately to get all the details from a negative, you need a research microscope
Zeiss a écrit:
the negatives were inspected directly on a research microscope. No other process involving projection (through even the best enlarging lens) or digitizing (in today’s best currently available scanners) is capable of transferring such high resolution values.
The new Planar T* 1,4/50 ZF went even further: It reached 320 lp/mm in the aperture range from f/5.6 to f/2.8, and 250 lp/mm at f/2


Reply

scan to tiff and sharpen on computer it is acceptable if you have tiny budget, on epson v500 medium format is great , 35mm is acceptable. www.scanassist.org affordable solution I use it to keep strips flat


Reply

Thankyou all for your input. I have widened my search by adding Windows XP in a VM to my Linux machine, so at least I am not now limited.

Special thanks to Ludo and Teo for the example scans. Ludo's Plustek is pretty impressive, and much better than I achieved on a friends version. Teo sent me some scans from his Dimage, and they looked really impressive too.

I shall raid my savings and see what I can turn up on ebay now I have more time on my hands Wink

Thanks again Cool


Reply

I find the Epson v500 ok. I use the film holders that came with it as I don't rate the ANR glass; if anything scans are softer.


Reply

martinsmith99 a écrit:
I find the Epson v500 ok. I use the film holders that came with it as I don't rate the ANR glass; if anything scans are softer.
I just tried my manky old V100 with the neg flat against the glass under the holder, and it wasn't any sharper, so I don't think I'll be going the V500 route. I think that comes under the heading of "flogging a dead horse" Laughing

Dedicated film scanner seems the way to go, either the Plustek or a Dimage III or IV etc.

...or a Coolscan if I get lucky on the lottery... some hope Sad


Reply

yinyangbt a écrit:
You have here a very good research instrument :
http://www.filmscanner.info/en/FilmscannerTestberichte.html
I would suggest a Minolta Dimage Scan Elite II , or , if you stretch a little , the 5400 . I use the Dimage III but it hasn't ICE and have a lot manual correct PP
CanoScan FS4000US and the Nikon Coolscan 4000 and IV ED could be options , if you find in the budget.


...and many people including myself agree with that link in that an Epson v750pro can only deliver about 2400dpi and the rest is software fiddle i.e. less "grainy or breakup of" pixels on enlarging the image.


Reply

It is a rather depressing fact that getting a good 35mm scanner is so expensive. I had an old CanoScan FS-2710 (?) which did a great job but is SCSI, so now obsolete and is not adaptable.

I have a lot of 35mm slides that I'd love to work with, but my budget is similar to yours- tiny! My Epson 4490 does a decent job with 120 film but 35mm looks awful.


Reply

I've had 8x12 scans from 35mm printed and they looked amazing. Don't worry about how they look at 100% on screen.


Reply

martinsmith99 a écrit:
I've had 8x12 scans from 35mm printed and they looked amazing. Don't worry about how they look at 100% on screen.


...of course and about 6mp scan with software fiddle can look good, and about 3mp looks very good on a computer screen...BUT what about all the stuff on the neg that gets left behind e.g. details in shadows etc that ordinary scanners can't reach Wink


Reply

A good flatbed scanner can do a reasonably good job of the shadow detail, I've found. That's the Dmax value. The closer to 4 the better.

Here's a link that compares many popular flatbed scanners along with several drum scanners, just to give you an idea of the resolution differences:

http://www.largeformatphotography.info/scan-comparison/

When you run the scan comparisons, it's most helpful to click the box that allows two scan sequences to be compared side by side.

One of the things I took away from this comparison was that there was essentially no difference between the sharpness from an Epson V750 and its immediate predecessor, the 4990. So since you're on a tight budget, look around for a clean used 4990. That's where I was a couple of years ago. Found a clean 4990 for $200 and it's worked well for what it is.

Another thing I took away from the comparisons was that a good drum scanner blows the flatbeds into the weeds.

Now, even though most good flatbed scanners can only manage resolutions of about 2000 ppi to 2400 ppi, it has been demonstrated that, if you scan your negatives or slides at the scanner's maximum claimed optical resolution (4800 ppi in the case of my Epson 4990), you will actually have a better image with more detail than if you scan the image at 2400 ppi. Not double the resolution -- not even close. But where you will see the improvement is in diagonal lines, where less aliasing will be apparent, and some fine line detail can possibly be improved. So once I discovered this, instead of scanning my negs at 2400 ppi, I'll scan at 4800 ppi and then reduce the image size to whatever I need. This way the ant-aliasing is preserved as is the additional detail.

I too bemoan the attitude toward scanning technology. It's totally unfounded. There are bilions of film images out there, just waiting to be scanned with high quality scanners. If that isn't a largely untapped resource, then I don't know what is. And because of this, many people, including myself, now duplicate their images with their DSLRs. It's fast, it's relatively cheap (already own the camera, all you need is a dupe rig), and the results are better.

Excalibur states that there is about 20 gigs of detail on a 35mm neg. Actually the theoretical maximum is closer to double that, but 20 gigs is probably a more realistic number when everything else is take into account. Still, 20 gigs ain't bad. Film has gotten a bad rap when compared to digital when it often hasn't deserved it. Scanning technology is more likely the real culprit. Which is why I dupe now. My 4990 gets used mostly for scanning medium format and Ektar. I still can't get Ektar to look right.


Dernière modification par cooltouch le Ven Déc 23, 2011 6:22 am ; modifié 1 fois au total


Reply

Useful info Michael, thankyou Cool

I admit I have never tried the upper end of the resolution setting on my existing scanner, rather assuming that 2400 means 2400. Having read much of the info here and at the various links offered, I am starting to understand why that's probably a bad decision on my part.

On the flip-side, I have abandoned digital for MF lenses due to frustration at crop sensors - until I can afford a full-frame DSLR, I'm staying with film. Because of that, I want a "good" film scanner, rather than an "ok" scanner. I can live with "ok" for quick scans for reference and making 'contact' prints, and indeed the little Kodak P461 excels at that particular job. But when I want to publish stuff here or produce a large print, I'd prefer to have the best I can afford. So far the old Minolta Dimage Elite seem to have the best reputation for sharpness.

All that said, I'm just scanning a neg at 4800 as we speak and already I can see improvements Cool

I like the idea of duping the negs with a camera. Maybe a high-res high-MP DSLR does have a place in my kit afterall. Hmm, lots of food for thought...


Reply

I think the Minolta Dimage Scan II III and IV are good choices that are fitting to a tighter budget like I had too . Only you have to correct manually the scratches and dust (PIA Laughing) If the films are OK, carefully manipulated and stored ,it's Ok

Here I am ( Hello, guys !) on a file scanned on Minolta Dimage III from Kodak Gold 100 .This is a crop 1/4 of the surface of the whole frame . First is directly from the scanner, second is slightly processed Sharp 50 luminance 18 recovery 45

Please click on the photo to see actual size








About the flatbed real resolution here is : http://www.filmscanner.info/en/EpsonPerfectionV700Photo.html and this is the best fladbed

About the dedicated 35mm Minolta Dimage IV scanner http://translate.google.ro/translate?sl=de&tl=en&js=n&prev=_t&hl=ro&ie=UTF-8&layout=2&eotf=1&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.filmscanner.info%2FMinoltaDimageScanDual4.html&act=url

About the Plustek 7600i real resolution : http://www.filmscanner.info/en/PlustekOpticFilm7600i.html

About my Dimage III that made the scan just posted : http://www.imaging-resource.com/SCAN/DSEIII/DSEIIIA.HTM


Reply

yinyangbt a écrit:
I think the Minolta Dimage Scan II III and IV are good choices that are fitting to a tighter budget like I had too . Only you have to correct manually the scratches and dust (PIA Laughing) If the films are OK, carefully manipulated and stored ,it's Ok

Here I am ( Hello, guys !) on a file scanned on Minolta Dimage III from Kodak Gold 100 .This is a crop 1/4 of the surface of the whole frame . First is directly from the scanner, second is slightly processed Sharp 50 luminance 18 recovery 45

Please click on the photo to see actual size








About the flatbed real resolution here is : http://www.filmscanner.info/en/EpsonPerfectionV700Photo.html and this is the best fladbed

About the dedicated 35mm Minolta Dimage IV scanner http://translate.google.ro/translate?sl=de&tl=en&js=n&prev=_t&hl=ro&ie=UTF-8&layout=2&eotf=1&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.filmscanner.info%2FMinoltaDimageScanDual4.html&act=url

About the Plustek 7600i real resolution : http://www.filmscanner.info/en/PlustekOpticFilm7600i.html

About my Dimage III that made the scan just posted : http://www.imaging-resource.com/SCAN/DSEIII/DSEIIIA.HTM



Very good...but one guy produced a shot with a 5DmkII and I blew it up to a picture of about 10 ft across and my scanned negs with a V750pro couldn't equal it (even a 1.5gig tif file). And I can't find the link to where a guy showed the difference between a V750pro and drum scan for a distant shot of a car in the desert, and as cooltouch said the difference is amazing.
Well there must be a technical reason why we can't get a flatbed scanner with drum scanner performance at a reasonable price, the optics surely are available for scanning and all you need is precision gearing for the scan, they can do it for a CD or DVD why not for a neg/slide Shocked


Reply

exactly !
In the first link (on the V700) at "image quality" the tests showed real (actual) resolution of aprox . 7 megapixels . It is some way to 20mp.
The Minolta Dimage III realises around 10.5 mp . The IV around 14-15mp .The Canon 4000FS goes around 18-20mp if I remember well . All in this price class (up to 200 L) .
Minolta Dimage 5400 Elite and the Nikon Coolscan IV and V are going around 20mp but we discuss here a tight budget , around 200 L
And good drum scans also more pricey


Reply

This is proving to be a fascinating topic for me. I hadn't realised how little I knew about scanners until now Embarassed


Reply

Even if there are many flatbed users (very good for web posting use and for medium format where the V700 performs briliantly) I learned (from others ,that really know this area Smile) that the best way to go for the moment ,if we want to scan 35mm film are the dedicated film scanners. Those on the new market are a few brands ,Plustek ,Quato and Reflecta mainly but they are not cheap and the quality is not the best at all the models.
The best way is to go on the used market where the Konica Minolta gear has the best quality price ratio .There were lots of such scanners produced they are in relative good shape ,with very good optic quality .Canon quit reltively soon this market , so the FS 4000 is not so easily found ,and the price is a bit higher .For best results and speed it requires a SCSI to USB card .
Finally , for those who afford it , the Nikon Coolscan IV ,V ,4000ED are excellent choices ,at higher price . I'd like one too .
At last ,Nikon coolscan 8000 or Minolta Dimage Scan Multi Pro are proffessional use excellent scanners .
If 8-10 megapixels is enough ,there are also the 2700-2900 dpi Coolscans : LS-30 ,LS-2000


Reply

This is definitely an interesting topic. I was just looking for the same things, since i just recently got interested in shooting film and was contemplating the cost of buying a scanner compared to having my photos scanned by the store at 4-5 euros additional cost and in probably quite shitty resolution (seems like less than my current computer screen ... Sad )

Although I won't need one just yet, I think it is a difficult choice between a secondhand one (like a minolta which seem reasonably priced) for which I may have to source some reasonable software and thus possibly adding the costs
or getting a new one like a base model plustek which seems to include a quite comprehensible software out of the box (even if it does not reach the full res advertised it is still quite reasonably priced) ... Confused


Reply

I've made a good choice for 100 E soft included Wink Just be careful and don't hurry Laughing