MFlenses - Une nouvelle vie à l’ère numérique
MFLenses 2026

Forum des objectifs à mise au point manuelle

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.
Pleins feux

Emplacement partenaire mis en avant sur la page d’accueil du forum.

Loose Tooth (C&C)
Voir le sujet précédent :: Voir le sujet suivant  


Reply

Hi!

I'm really looking for comments and criticism on this one. On composition, subject, post-processing, whatever....


"Concentrating on her loose tooth"
distance 0.5m, substantial pp in LR4

Cheers!


Reply

I probably do this too much, but if it were me, I would square crop it and convert to B&W or at least take most of the colour out.


Reply

If you feel like having a Photoshop session,
how about trying to blur the background?
Now it is too busy & steels the focus from the girl.
Also, try to turn back the colour intensity of the background.


Reply

The guy's *ss on the background could be blurred maybe ..

edit: I don't know Confused
is the message of the picture humorous?


Reply

kansalliskala a écrit:
is the message of the picture humorous?

Päivää! Sinulla on likainen mieli.
(At least, that is how I hope it is spelled.)


Reply

I don't think so she will be happy later if she will see this picture published.


Reply

It's a lovely picture of the little girl but I think you've learned the lesson to consider the background more carefully! Smile


Reply

peterqd a écrit:
It's a lovely picture of the little girl but I think you've learned the lesson to consider the background more carefully! Smile


+1 I just realise big .. in background , I did ask my daughter she is 23 now what she think about pose. She said no she wouldn't see similar pictures on public.


Reply

Background/bokeh is distracting
Focus sits a few cm behind the eyes

Artificial bokeh, cropping and B/W conversion with SilverEfex or similar would make it better.

Is it allowed to experiment a little with the pic?


Reply

Hi!

For what it's worth, this was a snapshot, it was not posed in any way. If it had been posed, the focus would have been better, and I can assure you the background would have been both less busy and less objectionable.

Now I'll handle the comments in relative order:

* martinsmith99, twinquartz, kansalliskala: I will try what you have suggested and post it here.

* Attila: Why do you think she would later be unhappy about this picture? It's pretty innocent, like everything else she does.

* peterqd: Thanks, I liked the picture also. I did see the background, but in "grab it now" shots like these, you don't have the choice at the time, you can only decide not to take the shot, or try to fix it in post.

* ForenSeil: Sure, play around, I'm interested to see what you come up with!

Many thanks for all of your thoughtful comments and criticism.

Cheers!


Reply

I can't explain on polite way I won't be rude certainly, I did ask my wife and daughter as a woman to confirm my feeling both said they were be unhappy with this picture.


Reply



I personally think a big boost in exposure and clarity makes it better



Is it a fail or is it better? Smile


Reply

There's nothing morbid in this photo unless someone wants to see it
it's just a child in a childish pose, at least that's what I see.
The photo is not really working for me. I think it's because of the close-up and the perfect frontal pose
because of that, it looks like a posed photograph, and this makes it lose spontaneity.
Also, with such closeups I always look for a neat focus on the eyes, which is missing here.
I would have preferred a whole figure framing and a more casual attitude. And B&W, because children are a sweet subject already,
in most cases colour makes them too sweet for good photography (my personal opinion).


Reply

I like it. Not sure what kind of critique I would do to a family snapshot.

I think the whole scene on the background just makes it more authentic, considering the kind of picture it is. The guy bending to help his children adds just the right amount of humour to the picture.

This is not a portrait, it is a snapshot of an ephemeris, how interesting would it be 20 years from now to look at this picture if it would be all technically perfect with a beautiful non-distracting background and professional pose?


Reply

I would have one more step to the right before takeing this photo, to capture the whole scene in background.

Left edge is not filled. Blurriness is fine, but more fun if the whole scene is in blurred background as a memory of a snap shot.
Other wise, I like the brighter version of it. Cropping/stronger framing will definitely help.

A nice scene after all. I can hear them too Very Happy


Reply

I think that you have used too wide lens for portrait. There is no 3D and image looks a bit flat.
Other than that I like the picture! Wink


Reply

jito a écrit:
Not sure what kind of critique I would do to a family snapshot.


The user submitted for critique.
It is my opinion that the photo can be good for a family album, but not enough for an exhibition or for a photographer's portfolio.


Reply

How about this?



Reply

Hi!

I think it improves it a bit, but at the expense of authenticity. It's hard to believe the processed photo.

Cheers!


ForenSeil a écrit:

I personally think a big boost in exposure and clarity makes it better



Is it a fail or is it better? Smile


Reply

I would square crop it and convert to B&W. But i have no detail idea about it. I am happy to see this post because i search such as post to know more .