MFlenses - Une nouvelle vie à l’ère numérique
MFLenses 2026

Forum des objectifs à mise au point manuelle

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.
Pleins feux

Emplacement partenaire mis en avant sur la page d’accueil du forum.

Which flash to choose?
Voir le sujet précédent :: Voir le sujet suivant  


Reply

I`ve recently decided that I want to buy a decent flash for my Pentax K-x, however I can`t seem to decide which one to choose. I`ve read multiple reviews one the pentaxforum and now I know that buying genuine pentax flash`es is off my list. Right now I`m choosing over the Metz-50af-1 , Metz52af-1 , Metz mecablitz 58 AF-1 digital. I know the last one would be the obvious choice but the price is a little bit too much for me so I hope some sort of discount would appear. But I would like to know which one has the best price/quality ratio, so ay sort of examples, suggestions , opinions are welcome. Thanks Smile


Reply

The biggest advantage of the Metz 58 af-1 is the non-TTL auto mode. You can only have P-TTL with A lenses on Pentax, so any adapted M42 or non-A K mount lens will just fire the flash full power every time. Of course you can use the other two in manual mode, but you'll have to do the calculations for distance to get the exposure right or just go by trial and error. The Metz 58 af-1 has a built in light sensor, just set the aperture and ISO on the flash to the aperture and ISO on the body and it takes care of the rest.

If you have a good selection of lenses that will allow you to use P-TTL, then the others will be fine for you.

I have a Yongnuo YN-560 that is full manual only, which I use a lot in controlled situations, but most of the time I use my Vivitar 285hv in auto mode.


Reply

I have an array of Vivitar 285's that I use underground. Plenty bright, and cheap enough in Charity shops.

That said, Manual only, and my application is different to most people's.


Reply

NewStuff a écrit:
I have an array of Vivitar 285's that I use underground. Plenty bright, and cheap enough in Charity shops.

That said, Manual only, and my application is different to most people's.


The 285HV isn't only manual, it has the old thyristor auto mode, that is what the 4 colors are for on the dial, they work really well.

You do have to be careful with those though, not all of them are safe for a digital body, the trigger voltage on the early ones is over 200 volts.


Reply

I have used the Vivitar flash for a few days now. Worked well with my K-X but I want to by a bit more modernized one. Also these flashes are rather had to find locally and I do not want to risk buying one abroad.


Reply

the older Pentax 280T is a good flash that is available second hand and fairly cheap.

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Pentax-AF-AF-280T-Shoe-Mount-Flash-boxed-/130824466550?pt=UK_CamerasPhoto_CameraAccessories_CameraFlashUnits_JN&hash=item1e75bef076


.


Reply

elliott a écrit:
NewStuff a écrit:
I have an array of Vivitar 285's that I use underground. Plenty bright, and cheap enough in Charity shops.

That said, Manual only, and my application is different to most people's.


The 285HV isn't only manual, it has the old thyristor auto mode, that is what the 4 colors are for on the dial, they work really well.

You do have to be careful with those though, not all of them are safe for a digital body, the trigger voltage on the early ones is over 200 volts.


Indeed, You are perfectly correct. My wording was reactive, and probably not best for this particular forum. Most people now are so used to E-TTL II and the like that they expect the flash to just work. Setting it yourself is, by most people's standards, Manual.

I run them off Radio triggers, I'd rather sacrifice a £20 trigger than a £300+ DSLR.


Reply

elliott a écrit:
NewStuff a écrit:
I have an array of Vivitar 285's that I use underground. Plenty bright, and cheap enough in Charity shops.

That said, Manual only, and my application is different to most people's.


The 285HV isn't only manual, it has the old thyristor auto mode, that is what the 4 colors are for on the dial, they work really well.

You do have to be careful with those though, not all of them are safe for a digital body, the trigger voltage on the early ones is over 200 volts.


The Vivitar 285HV are ALL save, but the 283 are not; some have low, some high voltage trigger depending on age. I usually measure it on teh hotshoe contacts using a simple voltmeter, works pretty well.


Reply

NewStuff a écrit:
elliott a écrit:
NewStuff a écrit:
I have an array. of Vivitar 285's that I use underground. Plenty bright, and cheap enough in Charity shops.

That said, Manual only, and my application is different to most people's.


The 285HV isn't only manual, it has the old thyristor auto mode, that is what the 4 colors are for on the dial, they work really well.

You do have to be careful with those though, not all of them are safe for a digital body, the trigger voltage on the early ones is over 200 volts.


Indeed, You are perfectly correct. My wording was reactive, and probably not best for this particular forum. Most people now are so used to E-TTL II and the like that they expect the flash to just work. Setting it yourself is, by most people's standards, Manual.

I run them off Radio triggers, I'd rather sacrifice a £20 trigger than a £300+ DSLR.


I prefer the auto thyristor flashes to TTL, it has been more reliable and predictable for me, not to mention it works with any camera and lens combination.