MFlenses - Une nouvelle vie à l’ère numérique
MFLenses 2026

Forum des objectifs à mise au point manuelle

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.
Pleins feux

Emplacement partenaire mis en avant sur la page d’accueil du forum.

LYTRO light field camera on the market now $399
Voir le sujet précédent :: Voir le sujet suivant  


Reply

http://www.engadget.com/2011/10/19/lytro-camera-hands-on-video/

The math behind is pretty amazing (I read the inventor's Ren Ng's PhD thesis he wrote at Stamford, the short paper on it is here:
http://graphics.stanford.edu/papers/lfcamera/lfcamera-150dpi.pdf ).

Here more for teh techies:
http://www.dpreview.com/articles/7237351494/lytro-light-field-camera-first-look-with-ren-ng


(c) dpreview.com

Ren Ng is the inventor and here is the "difficult part":
http://graphics.stanford.edu/papers/lfcamera/

Note the CONTAX camera their first prototype was built on !!

I agree that if this type of camera will be developed further, it might well be a "game changer" for the whole industry.


Dernière modification par kds315* le Jeu Oct 20, 2011 8:49 am ; modifié 1 fois au total


Reply

Very, very interesting to say the least!

However, I think it will fail on the consumer market. The average consumer is absolutely not interested in postprocessing the images. The resulting images must be as ready-to-use as possible. What do you think, Klaus?


Reply

In my understanding the camera does all the math involved; only if you want to refocus on certain parts of the image, a reprocessing will be needed, but also that the camera provides. But I agree, that even that might be too much for the average person who shoots only occasionally.


Reply

If this camera will go into production, it will surely be accompanied by a software where the used can click on an object and the photo is refocused on it.
I mean something that even a troglodyte can do. Very Happy


Reply

interactive sample pics here -

https://www.lytro.com/living-pictures/283

You can click around the image to set the focus, zoom etc.

Pretty low-res right now but there's a lot of promise.


Reply

I know about that but the question is, is it possible to set the DOF for teh whole image like at f4 or f8 or f16 etc. OR is it always like a f2 depending on where it is focused to??


Reply

kds315* a écrit:
I know about that but the question is, is it possible to set the DOF for teh whole image like at f4 or f8 or f16 etc. OR is it always like a f2 depending on where it is focused to??


A quick look at their site didn't show anything like that. But surely you could export a bunch of the f2 images and use image-stacking software? Maybe this will be included with version 2.0?

It's early days yet, hard to say if this will take off, fizzle, or maybe get bought out by one of the big players.

I see that the only option for hosting an image online is to use their official website, that's a red flag for me.

Hopefully they make enough money to hang around for a while and refine this idea.


Reply

Only available in the US for now.
And it will need to sport some more MPix to be interesting for most customers. Wink


Reply

fuzzywuzzy a écrit:

I see that the only option for hosting an image online is to use their official website, that's a red flag for me.


Umm, how (and why) would any other service have support for their “living images” (i.e. interactively focusing)? Since this is the only product creating them in this format, I don't see how it could be otherwise.

If you meant hosting a “regular” still image processed with the desktop software, of course you can put it anywhere. The software is Mac only for now, I would expect that to raise more red flags, although personally I think it's a sensible move—the camera clearly targets a certain “gadget hipster” crowd, and they will obviously have Macs.


Reply

LucisPictor a écrit:
Only available in the US for now.
And it will need to sport some more MPix to be interesting for most customers. Wink


One guy did the math on engadget.
If he is correct, then 1 picture will be about 20MB right out of the camera.

I read about the technology. If I get it, there is no aperture. It will always use the 2.0. So this dog knows only one trick.


Reply

Arkku a écrit:
fuzzywuzzy a écrit:

I see that the only option for hosting an image online is to use their official website, that's a red flag for me.


Umm, how (and why) would any other service have support for their “living images” (i.e. interactively focusing)? Since this is the only product creating them in this format, I don't see how it could be otherwise.

If you meant hosting a “regular” still image processed with the desktop software, of course you can put it anywhere. The software is Mac only for now, I would expect that to raise more red flags, although personally I think it's a sensible move—the camera clearly targets a certain “gadget hipster” crowd, and they will obviously have Macs.


I don't begrude them Mac-only support at this stage, they're just getting started and presumably a Windows version is in the works.

Their website is just a flash app that plays the picture data. There's no technical reason I couldn't host that flash app myself, but the vendor chooses to forbid it.

Here's my thing. I've got tintypes of my great-grandparents. A lot of water has gone under the bridge since then, but I can still show those pictures to my kids.

I'm not going to waste a shutter click on anything handcuffed to one particular company. Nothing against these guys, but companies come and go. If I don't fully control the picture I'm not interested.


Reply

fuzzywuzzy a écrit:

Their website is just a flash app that plays the picture data. There's no technical reason I couldn't host that flash app myself, but the vendor chooses to forbid it.


Ok, fair enough, although personally I have more issues with the Flash part than who hosts it. I would just host still images anyhow, or make my own little javascript to choose between the pre-rendered focus choices (which seems to be what their current site does). But it remains to be seen how open they will be about allowing others to create software to work with their images; in the end that's what matters, not how the online hosting is going to be at launch.

fuzzywuzzy a écrit:

Here's my thing. I've got tintypes of my great-grandparents. A lot of water has gone under the bridge since then, but I can still show those pictures to my kids.


I fail to see any relevance to web hosting; obviously your tintypes aren't online either (maybe some scans of them are, but similarly you could put still renders of the Lytro images online). Likewise you could show the digital Lytro images (possibly at much higher resolution) to people on your computer's screen.

(Of course you can make the argument that if Lytro doesn't ”open up” their file format & how to render it, then maybe you will be unable to run the software on some distant future computer—some people also claim this about raw files. But that's quite far off-topic already.)

fuzzywuzzy a écrit:

I'm not going to waste a shutter click on anything handcuffed to one particular company. Nothing against these guys, but companies come and go. If I don't fully control the picture I'm not interested.


Almost every camera manufacturer is all about “handcuffing” people to that company's products, i.e. proprietary mounts, lens/flash protocols, etc. That's also one reason why I prefer adapted manual focus lenses. =)


Reply

LucisPictor a écrit:
Only available in the US for now.
And it will need to sport some more MPix to be interesting for most customers. Wink


And that would probably require a bigger sensor and a super computer ? I would not invest my money in this company...


Reply

Arkku a écrit:

I fail to see any relevance to web hosting; obviously your tintypes aren't online either (maybe some scans of them are, but similarly you could put still renders of the Lytro images online). Likewise you could show the digital Lytro images (possibly at much higher resolution) to people on your computer's screen.


Ah yes but I have the choice of scanning them and putting them up, in their entirety, as good as the day they were taken. Nothing prevents me, I just haven't bothered.

Arkku a écrit:

(Of course you can make the argument that if Lytro doesn't ”open up” their file format & how to render it, then maybe you will be unable to run the software on some distant future computer—some people also claim this about raw files. But that's quite far off-topic already.)

Almost every camera manufacturer is all about “handcuffing” people to that company's products, i.e. proprietary mounts, lens/flash protocols, etc. That's also one reason why I prefer adapted manual focus lenses. =)


Agreed. I bought a Canon, and they don't publicize the EF specs, or their RAW formats. Fortunately everything has been reverse engineered, so I can buy a $10 focus confirm m42 adapters from Hong Kong, and there are open source libraries to handle the RAW files.

But as locked in as Canon would like to be, my genuine Canon Rebel and my genuine Canon 50mm/1.8 lens will shoot JPEGs. Those pictures are mine, forever, will be readable forever, whatever happens to Canon.

I guess what I'd be worried about is something that happened a few times in the MP3 player sector. A few companies sold MP3 player and had their own proprietary music store. When that company gets tired of losing money they kill the product and shut down the store. Everyone who bought proprietary music from those music stores is screwed, because they'll never be able to buy another player to use those files.

Anyway, that's probably enough from me Twisted Evil Twisted Evil


Reply

Spotmatic a écrit:
Very, very interesting to say the least!

However, I think it will fail on the consumer market. The average consumer is absolutely not interested in postprocessing the images. The resulting images must be as ready-to-use as possible. What do you think, Klaus?


There are many non - average consumers ( e.g. look at 'us' Wink ), gadget freaks, people who are enough tech savvy to do the necessary processing or have enough money to buy it just as a party gag, IMO this camera will be a HUGE success


Reply

fuzzywuzzy a écrit:

I'm not going to waste a shutter click on anything handcuffed to one particular company. Nothing against these guys, but companies come and go. If I don't fully control the picture I'm not interested.


Agreed. If viewing the images depends on the makers continuing to provide a web service to do so, there is a 95% chance that that camera and all images it has made in the past are useless within less than a decade. Indeed I would not buy such a thing until they have released a demonstrably working open source file decoder/viewer.


Reply

I thought I'd resurrect this thread because it would appear that things have been happening with the Lytro since the last time anyone has posted info about it here. Today I ran across a Lytro banner ad over at photo dot net and clicked on it to learn more. I gotta tell ya that this is one very interesting gadget, and as Klaus mentioned in his opening comments, it very well could be a game changer. Here's their website:

https://www.lytro.com/

The Lytro is being offered in 8 gig and 16 gig versions now. The 8 gig is $399 and the 16 gig is $499. Really, when you think about it, a 16 gig digicam with an 8x zoom for $500 is not such a bad deal. And then to have a camera that will do what it does, well that's rather remarkable. If one doesn't mind living with its restrictions -- which aren't really restrictions at all to a growing number of folks, I suspect.

But to me, it's possibly biggest drawback is the restriction that it is intended for displaying its images on the web only. Quoting from the Lytro website:

Keep in mind that the primary purpose of the Lytro Light Field Camera is creating living pictures to be shared online, not printing or exporting 2D images.

In fact, it limits exporting of images to jpg to a maximum of 1080x1080 pixels, so there's it's Achilles heel, IMO. But! Given the fact that we have a younger generation that is growing up "connected" -- will this sort of restriction even matter to them? I guess Lytro is banking on the probability that it won't. And you know, as I sit here and think about it -- with all the image manipulation that I've done over the past few years -- literally thousands of images worth -- I have printed out to hardcopy less than a dozen. Even those images I've sold, I've handled all online, but those images wound up in books as 2D flat images. But here's the kicker -- I suspect that, even tho I supplied hi-rez images to the buyers, the actual image size they wound up going with in their publications might have worked fine at 1080 pixels. So even in some limited circumstances, a Lytro's 2D output may be sufficient. I would not be surprised though if future iterations of this camera (or firmware or desktop software, whatever) support higher rez exports than the current model does.