MFlenses - Une nouvelle vie à l’ère numérique
MFLenses 2026

Forum des objectifs à mise au point manuelle

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.
Pleins feux

Emplacement partenaire mis en avant sur la page d’accueil du forum.

Decent cheaper AF lenses for EOS 450D
Voir le sujet précédent :: Voir le sujet suivant  


Reply

I have had problems with my EOS 450D. The original screen is useless for focusing manually so I fitted a cheap Chinese replacement with a split screen, it was awful, and needed shimming but I managed to break the metal retaining clip so to fix it I glued the original screen back in. Therefore, I'm stuck with using AF lenses because trying to focus a manual lens with the awful screen is an exercise in futility.

I do have one AF lens - a brand new Sigma AF IF 28-105 mm F/4.0-5.6. I've used it once and it's really awful, not sharp at all, weak contrast and colours, it really offends my eyes that are accustomed to sharp prime lenses.

My budget is small and prime AF lenses for EOS are not so easy to find and not so cheap, so I'm going to have to buy an AF zoom lens or two.

Now, I know that I'm not going to find anything that can stand upto my collection of old manual primes, but I do want something with decent IQ.

So, what do people recommend? My first purchase needs to be something in the wide to normal range, such as a 28-70 or 28-105. A longer lens like a 70-210 or 100-300 will come second.

I'm not worried about AF speed, I just want decent IQ, all other considerations are secondary by far.


Dernière modification par iangreenhalgh1 le Jeu Oct 03, 2013 5:19 pm ; modifié 1 fois au total


Reply

Believe it or don't, the EF-S 18-55 kit lens that comes with these cheapo Canons is actually quite good. The type II lens, and the latest, the "STM," are the ones you want to consider. NOT THE TYPE I.

I got a type II with my Canon XS (1000D) and I have been quite pleased with it. I've taken some macro shots with it that are surprisingly detailed. And for just general photography, it has worked great. I did a bit of reading up on the new STM version and it appears to have been heavily optimized for video work. It has a seven-blade round iris aperture, for example, so the bokeh will be nice and smooth. The focusing motor has been optimized for quietness. And more. Best of all, it's still quite a deal brand new, around $160US or so. And it looks like the type II is still available new, and it can be had for about $120US (new).

I've heard good things about the EF-S 55-250mm, but I haven't seen a need to buy one. I have a couple of legacy EF lenses that I use for telephotos: Canon's very first tele zoom for EOS, a 70-210/4, and I have an EF 75-300/4-5.6 that came as a kit lens with an Elan II that I don't own anymore. This 75-300 is the type II. The more recent 75-300s get a bad rap because they're just about all plastic, including the mount, and feel cheap. Mine has as metal mount, so it isn't quite as cheap and plasticky as the later ones. I have found from my own photography that the 75-300/4-5.6 II can deliver critically sharp images with lots of contrast. The following two images were taken with my XS (1000D) and the 75-300 at ISO 100. You can practically count rivets on the 100% crops. The photos were taken handheld as the "Angels" flew by.




Oh, and here's a shot I took with my 18-55 -- from a Chicago trip I took a few years ago. Not bad for a cheapo kit lens, you ask me. No post processing was done to this image at all. Oh wait -- that's not true. I did correct the image for perspective distortion, but that was it.


Dernière modification par cooltouch le Jeu Oct 03, 2013 3:52 pm ; modifié 1 fois au total


Reply

Thankyou Michael, that's very valuable. I had two copies of the first version of the 18-55, they were not good. I have heard the IS version is much better and judging by that tower, it certainly is.

The Angels shots are very sharp indeed, well done!


Reply

Try the ef usm 35-135 really very very good, available for a reasonable price on the bay if you shop around a bit. Its my preferred walk around lens


Reply

Cheers Trev. Would that be the f3.5-4.5 version or the f4-5.6 one?


Reply

cheapest 1:1 macro - very sharp wide open - is probably Sigma 50/2.8

Cliquez ici pour voir sur Ebay


Reply

The EF 28-105 is a more than decent lens.
From the APS-lenses I really can recommend the Sigma 17-70. The older version 2.8-4.5 is cheaper but does not sport an IS, in contrast to the new 2.8-4.0.


Reply

Ian, its the 4-5.6 version, has had very good write ups in the past and being a true USM is practically silent in operation and you can manually override the auto focus as well.


Reply

Thanks guys, this is what I need to know. Smile

A lot of the choice depends on what I can find cheaply, I just need to make sure I avoid picking a lemon.


Reply

I would look for 75-200/4.5 (does it exist for CAF?), 60-300, 28-70/3.5-4.5 HSAF
Maybe the 28-210 UMCS but quite rare and expensive

Sigma 50/2.8 if you can get it

But then I don't know zilch about Canon - whether these exist at all and about compatibility with various CAF bodies


AF confirm doesn't help?


Reply

I am selling an EOS 300 with a nice Canon 28-90 zoom. Perhaps this would be good. I dont know if the screen will fit yours.


Reply

philslizzy a écrit:
I am selling an EOS 300 with a nice Canon 28-90 zoom. Perhaps this would be good. I dont know if the screen will fit yours.


Have you offered it here?


Reply

A bit more advice to pass along: I own a copy of the Canon EF 28-80mm zoom, I think it's either the II or III. I used to own another one that was identical and was really quite soft in focus. I sold it. But you know what? Even this one that I still own will not win any awards as far as sharpness goes, so I really do NOT recommend the Canon 28-80. I would avoid all flavors of it, just to be on the safe side.

I also own a Tamron 24-70mm f/3.3-5.6 Aspherical that I bought back in 1994 new. It comes new with its own hood. It was fairly cheap back in 1994 -- about $150. So these days it should be even cheaper. I've always felt that it has delivered excellent images, whether I was shooting slides through my old EOS film cameras or digital with my current DSLR. So I can recommend this one, although the focal range is not all that useful for APS-C.


Reply

I also have a couple of very-low-AFlenses for my Canons. Carefully chosen with the highest-quality-per-lower-price ratio.

Widewise, I have a very old EF 24-85. These come VERY cheap - I found mine in a lot sale where they sold, like, 10 of them,
because Canon people turn their nose up to them. I must have paid something in the magnitude order of 30 to 40 Euros...
The quality is much better than what I used to get from the kit lens 18-55 that I got with the 400D, and what's more, contrarily
to the EF-S 18-55, the old 24-85 also works on full frame (just in case).

Obviously, 24 on a APS-C camera is not that wide... but if you need a 18 or 20 mm lens, you can use one of your manual lenses,
because you don't really need to focus a 20mm lens, just guesstimate the distance, and you'll be fine.

Telewise, I got a 55-250, which delivers very sharp images. It might not have the speed and luscious bokeh of the L lenses, but hey,
if I want that, i have my Planars at hand...

Finally I have a 1.8/85 prime, but it's out of your price range I guess, so I don't include in samples.

Here's one sample per each of the two lenses:

EF 24-85



100% crop:




EF-S 55-250



100% crop (note: ISO 2000, front-focused, and subject was walking fast) :



Reply

Thanks guys, this is all very useful.

Orio, I know the 24-85, and have heard before that it's a good lens. I wish I could find out for 30-40 EU, they tend to fetch 2-3x that much on ebay uk, but I'll keep looking. I agree that for ultra-wide I can get away with hyperfocal use of a manual. Sadly, I don't have anything wider than 28mm that will fit my EOS apart from a Sigma 21-35 that will only work wide open.

Michael, I have read nothing but bad about the old 28-80 and 28-90 kit lenses so I have ignored them.


Reply

LucisPictor a écrit:
philslizzy a écrit:
I am selling an EOS 300 with a nice Canon 28-90 zoom. Perhaps this would be good. I dont know if the screen will fit yours.


Have you offered it here?


I had put it on ebay minutes before seeing this topic. It sold within minutes!!! My BIN was high enough for as decent profit, low enough to sell before all the others.


Reply

I'm liking the results from the EF 28-135, pictured on the right. Got it for $200 and will add its companion the 70-300 USM IS, but will
run close to double in cost, due to IS.



Reply

iangreenhalgh1 a écrit:
I had two copies of the first version of the 18-55, they were not good. I have heard the IS version is much better...
This seems to be true. The non-IS 18-55 lens which came with my old 400D was not so great, being slow to focus and seriously lacking in low-light situations. Build quality seemed rather sketchy, as well.

When I grabbed an IS version of the same lens, I was very impressed with it. Fast focus, great build quality, able to focus much faster and more accurately in low lighting, and it allowed me to handhold a clear shot at noticeably slower shutter speeds. These lenses tend to sell cheaply; I grabbed mine a few years ago for under US $90. I'm seriously considering adding one to my collection again, as it's really a very useful lens under many different situations.


Reply

cooltouch a écrit:
A bit more advice to pass along: I own a copy of the Canon EF 28-80mm zoom, I think it's either the II or III. I used to own another one that was identical and was really quite soft in focus. I sold it. But you know what? Even this one that I still own will not win any awards as far as sharpness goes, so I really do NOT recommend the Canon 28-80. I would avoid all flavors of it, just to be on the safe side.

I also own a Tamron 24-70mm f/3.3-5.6 Aspherical that I bought back in 1994 new. It comes new with its own hood. It was fairly cheap back in 1994 -- about $150. So these days it should be even cheaper. I've always felt that it has delivered excellent images, whether I was shooting slides through my old EOS film cameras or digital with my current DSLR. So I can recommend this one, although the focal range is not all that useful for APS-C.


I recommend this lens as well, it served me very well on my old EOS 600 shooting Ektrachrome and Fujichrome. I bought it when the kit lens broke ( I parked a Range Rover on my kit bag and broke the whole frigging lot ! ) and the insurance paid up 'new for old' - I hated the kit lens anyway, and bought the Tamron on reccomendation, I didn't regret it. I still have the lens and the EOS 600 Ian, and as it's the only EOS stuff I've got now that I've given away a Sigma UC2 70-210, I might be tempted to sell / swop the lens and camera. Confused


Reply

SkedAddled a écrit:
iangreenhalgh1 a écrit:
I had two copies of the first version of the 18-55, they were not good. I have heard the IS version is much better...
This seems to be true. The non-IS 18-55 lens which came with my old 400D was not so great, being slow to focus and seriously lacking in low-light situations. Build quality seemed rather sketchy, as well.

When I grabbed an IS version of the same lens, I was very impressed with it. Fast focus, great build quality, able to focus much faster and more accurately in low lighting, and it allowed me to handhold a clear shot at noticeably slower shutter speeds. These lenses tend to sell cheaply; I grabbed mine a few years ago for under US $90. I'm seriously considering adding one to my collection again, as it's really a very useful lens under many different situations.


+1. I've enjoyed mine. I was also rather surprised and very pleased with its abilities as a macro lens, too. It focuses down really close and is very sharp.

Check out these pix of some flowers I took right after a rain shower. Again, mine is the 2nd version, the 18-55 IS.

This first one is sized for the web, and is the full photo. It was shot at ISO 400, so the noise is fairly obvious. The depth of field is shallow, so it doesn't look like anything particularly special. But there's some interesting stuff hiding in this photo.


This next one is a 100% crop of some large raindrops on a petal. Notice the hair-like structures along the right edge of the petal.


This is also a 100% crop, this time one of the -- what? Stamens? Pistels? Never can remember which is which -- of one of the flowers after the petals have fallen off, visible on the original image over to the left of center. Good detail was captured here.


So all I'm saying is, for a non-macro lens, it can pull off some choice macro shots if you don't happen to have a true macro handy.


Reply

Thanks guys, all very helpful.

David, that Tammy 24-70 sounds like it could be the answer to my quest, s I'm definitely interested. I would be more than happy o open up my treasure chest to let you peruse for something in exchange. Smile

I think, long-term, for my AF outfit, I will go for a Sony SLT camera because of the excellence and cheapness of the old 1980s 'beercan' style Minoltas. I have the 4/70-210 and am keeping my eye out for others cheap.

There's nothing wrong per se with the EOS 450D, but in the long run, I would like to replace it, so I'm not looking to spend much on lenses for it, just one good one will do, such as the Tammy 24-70 or the Canon 24-85.


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 a écrit:
Thanks guys, all very helpful.

David, that Tammy 24-70 sounds like it could be the answer to my quest, s I'm definitely interested. I would be more than happy o open up my treasure chest to let you peruse for something in exchange. Smile

I think, long-term, for my AF outfit, I will go for a Sony SLT camera because of the excellence and cheapness of the old 1980s 'beercan' style Minoltas. I have the 4/70-210 and am keeping my eye out for others cheap.

There's nothing wrong per se with the EOS 450D, but in the long run, I would like to replace it, so I'm not looking to spend much on lenses for it, just one good one will do, such as the Tammy 24-70 or the Canon 24-85.


Might solve my problem as well, as in another thread was looking for AF zoom under 80mm for a Nikon F-401..well my son has parked his 400D at my house because he doesn't use it much, and you don't think much of the kit lens EF-S 18-55mm..well I'd like a decent lens but the problem is all I want with either camera is taking shots of my grandchildren as with active kids I'm getting too many OOF shots on manual focus, so seems silly to spend too much money on a lens.


Reply

We should be up the Lakes before mid November Ian, if you can wait until then I'll bring the camera and lens up and I's sure we can do a swap for something nice. Wink


Reply

Oh I'm in no hurry, so that would be fine. I think I have the very thing for you actually, but you can have a good peruse and pick. Smile

BTW, I'm on the lookout for any of the old 'beercan' style Minolta AF lenses. I have the 4/70-210 already.


Reply

iangreenhalgh1 a écrit:
Thanks guys, this is what I need to know. Smile

A lot of the choice depends on what I can find cheaply, I just need to make sure I avoid picking a lemon.

All I can tell you about Sigma QC is that it varies like hell. My Canon 10D came with a Sigma 28-105/ 2.8-4.0 Aspherical, and I found it moderately good. Results vary widely, according to a quick google about it, with some complaining and some praising. If I was buying a similar AF-only lens now, I don't think I'd bother with this one, and instead spend the money on a reputedly good alternative like the Canon 28-105/3.5-4.5. So many good lenses have been out for so long now that I wouldn't risk money on a dodgy old Sigma.