| Voir le sujet précédent :: Voir le sujet suivant |
| Auteur |
Message |
Mir
 Inscrit le: 07 Fév 2011 Messages: 990 Localisation: Montreal, Canada
Expire: 2017-09-30
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 12:49 am Sujet du message: Minolta's best |
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 12:49 am Sujet du message: Minolta's best |
|
|
Mir wrote:
Lets say one wants to gather and collect the best lenses from Minolta and make a nice set of lenses for himself.
Lets say 5 or 6 lenses.
Lets not get in never ending stiff-necked arguments, but rather do like fellow member forenSeil did in another post.
Be precise on the exact version, if many versions exist and support your say by disclosing your sources and references.
And i'll take the liberty of quoting fellow member ForenSeil to start this thread...
| ForenSeil a écrit: |
| Once I read an old 135mm test ranking made by Colorfoto January 1978 I think, the 135/2.8 Sonnar T* was third place, Elmarit-R 135/2.8 first place and Minolta MD Tele Rokkor 135/2.8 (4 element version) between them, all very close(...) |
According to http://minolta.eazypix.de/lenses/index.html And if we follow ForenSeil, only the:
1977 and 1978 MD Tele Rokkor(-X) with 4/4 lens design and ∅55 filter thread fit the bill....
So i guess that's a start.... _________________ "Obsta principiis, finem respice"
"There is a fine line between hobby and mental illness"
MISC: Tamron SP 35-80 (01A), Auto Chinon Tomioka 1.4/55, Primoplan 2/58, Tokina AT-X 2.5/90, Tamron SP 5,6/300 (54B)
ZEISS: WG Distagon 2.8/25, WG Distagon 2.8/35 HFT, WG Planar HFT 1.4/50, Ultron 1.8/50, Biotar 2/5,8cm, WG Sonnar 2.8/85, WG Sonnar HFT 2.8/135
VOIGTLÄNDER : Ultron Aspherical 1.8/21, Ultron 2/28, Nokton Aspherical 1.2/35, Nokton Classic 1.4/40, Nokton 1.2/50, Nokton Aspherical 1.5/50, Color-Heliar 2.5/75
MINOLTA: MD 3.5/35-70 Macro, MD 1.2/50, MC Rokkor-X 1.2/58, MD Macro 3.5/50
LEITZ: ELMARIT-R 2.8/28, SUMMICRON-R 2/35 (II), SUMMICRON-R 2/50 (II), TELE ELMARIT-M 2,8/90 (Thin), ELMARIT-R 2.8/135
CANON RF: 3.5/25, 2.8/28, 2/35, 1.2/50, 1.4/50, 1.5/50, Serenar 1.8/50, Serenar 1.9/50, 2/85, 2/100, 3.5/100
LTM : Konishiroku Hexanon 1.9/50, YASHICA YASHINON 1.8/5cm, FUJINON L 2/5cm, CHIYODA KOGAKU SUPER ROKKOR 1.8/5cm, CHIYOKO SUPER ROKKOR C 2/5cm, TOKYO KOGAKU Topcor-S 2/5cm, Nippon Kogaku NIKKOR-H.C 2/5cm, KMZ Jupiter-8 2/5cm
DKL : VOIGTLÄNDER SKOPAREX 3,4/35, SEPTON 2/50, DYNAREX 3,4/90, SUPER-DYNAREX 4/135, Scheiner-Kreuznach Retina-Xenon 1,9/50
And a small Minolta AF set: 2.8/20, 2/28, 1.4/35, 1.4/50, 2/100, 4.5/100-200, 4/28-135
@we3fotography
@7plus_pictures
@_whats.that.car_ |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
Attila
 Inscrit le: 24 Fév 2007 Messages: 58002
Expire: 2025-11-18
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 1:42 am Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 1:42 am Sujet du message: |
|
|
Attila wrote:
I have a few Minolta what I like really, 100mm PF 2.0, Minolta latest MD 20mm, 24mm 35mm 1.8 ,50mm f1.2 I didn't like much several earlier ones, probably all good enough to anyone |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
ForenSeil
 Inscrit le: 15 Avr 2011 Messages: 2731 Localisation: Kappeln, Schleswig-Holstein, Germany.
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 1:46 am Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 1:46 am Sujet du message: |
|
|
ForenSeil wrote:
I'm a big Minolta fan!
Minolta was a top maker like Nikon, Zeiss or Leitz etc.
Minolta 24/2.8 (all except latest MD version with 49mm filter screwmount and without "Rokkor" which is nothing special) - very sharp and very nice colors. The other wide angle Minoltas are generally also very good.
Minolta M-Rokkor 90/4 (Leica M) - light and tiny but very sharp lens, similar to Leica Elmar-C 90/4
Minolta 58/1.2 and 50/1.2 - both awesome!
Minolta MD 50/2 - Pssssst... like the Minolta 135/2.8 often underrated but optically imho one of the very best manual 50ies around, best CA control ever, decent sharpness wide open and ultra sharp stopped down, finest Minolta colors, imho better than 50/1.4 and even a little better than the 50/1.7. I once made a direct comparision on NEX-5N between the MD 50/2, the MD 50/1.4, Hexanon 5X/1.4;5X/1.7;5X1.8, Carl Zeiss HFT Planar 50/1.8 and -believe it or not - the MD 50/2 was better @F2 than all other @F2 - the best is - it can be had for less than 20€. Only drawback ist that it's partiall made of plastic.
EDIT: There are at least 3 optically different Minolta 50/2, I think I'm refering about the latest 1981< one.
Minolta MD 200/2.8 and 200/4 - Psssst.... two more lesser known but optically awesome gemstones, both designs containing finest ED glass.
Minolta MC/MD 50/1.4 - Very good, one of the very best 50/1.4's you can get in the league for less then 100€. The MD was my most used lens for a long time, but I don't like to use mine anymore since I have FF, as sweet spot wide open and F2 is very tiny. But works nice on APS-C. The MC 50/1.4 PG is said to be best of them, though all are very good.
http://forum.mflenses.com/minolta-md-rokkor-50mm-f1-4-t49267,highlight,%2Bminolta.html
Minolta M-Rokkor 40/2 (Leica M) - slightly nervous bokeh wide open but except that an optically outstanding lens, tiny as a thimble, even with adapter. Often sold in bundle with very nice Minolta CLE rangefinder. Optically it's identical with Leica Summicron-C 40/2 I think.
Minolta 100/2 - often very expensive but rated to be one of the best and sharpest potrait lenses ever
Minolta 135/2.8 STF - expensive but unique, very sharp and bokeh is so smooth that it becomes weird!
Minolta 16/2.8 Fisheye - a very good fisheye, also to modern standards, design ist practically unchanged still in production (now by Sony) since the 60ies, so good that also even Leitz bought license from Minolta
Minolta 500/8 Mirror - Expensive but one of the very best mirror lenses. Latest version should be optically identical with Leica Mirror Telyt and Sony AF Mirror as far as I know (http://tinyurl.com/nbfxvft)
Minolta MD 250/5.6 Mirror - As small as a normal 50/1.4 lens and very good IQ. Fetches usually ultra high prices on Ebay due rarity and demand in asia.
Minolta 35-70/3.5 Macro - Best zoom lens at it's times and still very good today (it's still able to beat several modern Zeiss zooms like the 1k€ Zeiss FE Tessar 24-70 in some excercises!), it's optically identical with more expensive Leica R 35-70/3.5. Can be had for 40€ or something like that.
Minolta MD 70-200/4 - Well kown, very good reputations, optically identical to the later AF version
Minolta 75-200/4.5 - Pssst.... less known but was the very best zoom in it's range when it was released in 1978 until it was topped first by Nikon and than a little later massivly by Leitz Vario-Elmar-R 80-200/4.5... it did cost 1250DM (nearly 1400€) and has an complex (expensive) 15/11 design. Lens was not very succesful due price, the more common successor MD/AF 70-200/4 was very good aswell and did cost a fraction. Today the 75-200 is often much cheaper because it's less known but it's actually not inferior.
Minolta Macros - All Minolta macros primes (100/4, 100/3.5, 100/2.8 and the 50mm) are very sharp lenses at close up range, also to modern standards. But especially the 50mm is slightly inferior at infinity to modern macro primes, and the at least the 100/4 is not colors corrected for Minolta standards, so these are not perfect lenses for general purposes, they are good macro workhorses only.
And of course all Minolta G APO primes - made under highest standards for professional use, quite expensive but also still top of the top of the notch, in the same class as Leica- or Zeiss Apo lenses _________________ I'm not a collector, I'm a tester
My camera: Sony A7+Zeiss Sonnar 55/1.8
Current favourite lenses (I have many more):
A few macro-Tominons, Samyang 12/2.8, Noritsu 50.7/9.5, Rodagon 105/5.6 on bellows, Samyang 135/2, Celestron C8 2000mm F10
Most wanted: Samyang 24/1.4, Laowa 100/2.8 2x, Nikon 200/2 ED
Dernière modification par ForenSeil le Mar Avr 08, 2014 2:07 am ; modifié 16 fois au total |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
lukias
Inscrit le: 09 Juin 2011 Messages: 11 Localisation: NZ
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 1:56 am Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 1:56 am Sujet du message: |
|
|
lukias wrote:
http://minolta.eazypix.de/lenses/index.html
Based on that you'd be forgiven for thinking the previous 3 versions were the same also... specs basically identical... even the celtics.
As far as respected, obtainable and lightweight I'd say MD 20mm 2.8, 24mm Rokkor(late MC), MD 35mm 1.8, MD 50mm 1,4(55mm), 85mm F2. Naturally people will mention 58mm 1.2, 100mm F2, 135mm F2... but hardly easily sourced or cheap. |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
Lightshow
 Inscrit le: 04 Nov 2011 Messages: 3666 Localisation: Calgary
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 2:33 am Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 2:33 am Sujet du message: |
|
|
Lightshow wrote:
I won't be selling my MC 28/2.5 or 58/1.2 ever.
I have the 50/1.8 & 85/2.8 in LTM en route to me.
The MC 50/1.4 & 24/2.8 are on my list to get. _________________ A Manual Focus Junky...
One photographers junk lens is an artists favorite tool.
My lens list
http://www.flickr.com/photos/lightshow-photography/ |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
Tedat
 Inscrit le: 08 Nov 2011 Messages: 800 Localisation: Berlin/Germany
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 6:26 am Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 6:26 am Sujet du message: |
|
|
Tedat wrote:
Minolta F2.8 [T4.5] 135mm STF: my favorite lens of all.. nothing can create a smoother bokeh
Minolta AF 2/100mm: probably my sharpest lens
Minolta AF 1.4/85mm G: the reason why I'm not even looking for something like a Zeiss Planar 1.4/85
Minolta AF 2.8/200mm APO G HS: best Tele I ever owned
Minolta AF 4-4.5/28-135mm: the Zoom which should be labeled "G".. exceptional! _________________ Regards
Jan
flickr
Sony A7RM2
Contax T*: Distagon 4/18, Distagon 2/28, Distagon 1.4/35, PC-Distagon 2.8/35, Planar 1.4/50, Planar 1.4/85, Planar 2/100, Planar 2/135, S-Planar 2.8/60, Tessar 2.8/45, Mirotar 8/500, Vario Sonnar 3.4/35-70, Vario Sonnar 4.5-5.6/100-300
Carl Zeiss for Rollei QBM: F-Distagon 2.8/16 HFT, Distagon 2.8/25, Planar 1.4/50 HFT, Sonnar 2.8/85
Konica Hexanon AR: 2.8/21, 1.2/57
Other: Minolta F2.8 [T4.5] 135mm STF, Meopta Meostigmat 1.4/70, Tokina AT-X 2.5/90.. and lots of early M42 Yashinon, Rikenon and Mamiya lenses |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
memetph
 Inscrit le: 01 Déc 2013 Messages: 940 Localisation: Poland
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 6:30 am Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 6:30 am Sujet du message: |
|
|
memetph wrote:
I started buying Rokkors two weeks ago. They are cheaper than M42 , PK, FD here in PL.
MC 50/1.4 PG 45 euros, MC 28/3.5 SG 35 euros, MD 45/2 20 euros, MD 75/200 4.5 22euros. All in very good condition.
I had no time to make extensive tests but I am happy with the first shots.
The zoom is an impressive piece of optic and it is mint.
There are some very good opinions about it especially in Germany and also more critical. I hope that unsere Freunde are right. |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
iangreenhalgh1
 Inscrit le: 18 Mar 2011 Messages: 15679
Expire: 2014-01-07
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 8:22 am Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 8:22 am Sujet du message: |
|
|
iangreenhalgh1 wrote:
Rokkor-SG 3.5/28 is an amazing lens, probably the best 28 I've ever found, it has 7 elements unlike the later version that has only 5
Rokkor-PF 1.7/50 and MD 1.7/50 both among the best 50s available, don't believe the nonsense about the 2/50 being better, there is nothing to choose between them
MD 2/45 pancake, very underrated, has wonderful colours and character, the 1.7/50 is a tiny bit sharper but the 2/45 has a character all it's own that I really like
3.5-4.5/28-85 superb lens, better than the more hyped 4/35-70 _________________ I don't care who designed it, who made it or what country it comes from - I just enjoy using it! |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
vlousada
 Inscrit le: 11 Déc 2010 Messages: 345 Localisation: Portugal
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 8:30 am Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 8:30 am Sujet du message: |
|
|
vlousada wrote:
Minolta lenses are very good..
I have several and still looking to add some more.
The best I have tried so far are:
- Rokkor 1.2/58mm
- Rokkor 2.0/100mm
- Rokkor 1.8/35mm
- Rokkor 1.7/85mm
All them are highly recommended.
Like you, also I am putting effort to collect 6-7 TOP Minolta lenses...
So, I am looking after:
1) Rokkor 2.0/135mm
2) Rokkor 1.2/50mm
3) Rokkor 2.8/24mm _________________ Regards,
VITOR
-------
SELLING:
Please ask
Dernière modification par vlousada le Jeu Avr 03, 2014 12:10 pm ; modifié 1 fois au total |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
Aanything
 Inscrit le: 27 Août 2011 Messages: 2187 Localisation: Piacenza, Italy
Expire: 2014-05-30
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 8:38 am Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 8:38 am Sujet du message: |
|
|
Aanything wrote:
I've had some minoltas, both sr and af, the ones I remember as outstanding for various reasons are:
MC Rokkor PG 1.4/50
MD Rokkor 1.7/50 (and AF 1.7/50, i suspect they are more or less the same)
MC Tele Rokkor QD 2.8/135
the 35/70 zoom, both the MC/MD version and the AF "mini beercan" one
AF 70/210 f4 "beercan"
the recently acquired MC Rokkor SI 2.5/28, which is quickly becoming one of my favourites, because of a great mix of technical qualities and character.
MC Rokkor PF 85/1.7
I need to add that the second MC line is one of my favourite series ever in terms of feel/build quality. _________________ C&C and editing of my pics are always welcome
Samples from my lenses
My gear
My Flickr |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
Basilisk
 Inscrit le: 21 Mar 2013 Messages: 356 Localisation: UK
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 12:00 pm Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 12:00 pm Sujet du message: |
|
|
Basilisk wrote:
I found a lovely rokkor MC 100mm f2.5, not as sought after as the f2, but a very nice performer (only tested on crop so far). Seems a bit of an oddity, but probably worth getting if the price is right. Not many for sale. |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
woodrim
 Inscrit le: 14 Jan 2010 Messages: 4069 Localisation: Charleston
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 1:38 pm Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 1:38 pm Sujet du message: |
|
|
woodrim wrote:
I've used Minolta since 1973, yet I've had very few Minolta lenses, mainly because I couldn't afford them back then. I was fortunate to get the MC 1.4/50 PG with my first camera and I still love the lens. I believe from what I have read, it's highly regarded among the 50s.
The 2.8/135 four element actually includes the MC version right before the MD. Some folks at this German site have done a good job helping to identify the lenses: http://www.artaphot.ch/minolta-sr/objektive
From what I have read, but not personal experience, the 2/100 seems a highly regarded lens. Same for the 24mm. So far, these are all Rokkors. I think there was a little slip when the dropped the Rokkor label, but why I don't know. However, some zooms were very good too, as far as zooms go. The only AF and only zoom I use is the Minolta 35-105 (second version) and it amazes me every time. _________________ Regards,
Woodrim |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
aoleg
 Inscrit le: 22 Fév 2008 Messages: 1387 Localisation: Berlin, DE
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 2:12 pm Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 2:12 pm Sujet du message: |
|
|
aoleg wrote:
Rokkor 50/1.4 (all versions are great, I believe there were 4 or 5 of them). One of the best fast fifties. Better than SMC Takumar 50/1.4.
Rokkor 85/2. The sharpest 85mm f/2 lens I ever seen. Sharp, sharp, sharp! Very compact, too, and great flare resistance. If you were to say negative things about this lens, they would be the plastic aperture control ring, and maybe slightly harsh background rendering (mind you, not harsh harsh, but compared to 85/1.7...) These still go for peanuts. MD 85/2 is an undiscovered gem.
Rokkor 85/1.7. Unfortunately, they are well known, so their prices are high. Other than that, great creamy bokeh, natural contrast and nice colors. I prefer this lens when shooting portraits under strong sunlight.
Rokkor MD 100/2.5. I can only vouch for MD version because the older MC (which is, by the way, a different optical construction) is much more difficult to convert to EOS. Anyway; the MD 100/2.5 is a great portrait lens, with a more gentle rendering compared to Nikkor AIS 105/2.5.
Rokkor MD (and late MC) 135/2.8 with 55mm filter ring. In other words, the version with 4 lens in 4 groups construction (Minolta had 3 different 135/2.8's; the 4/4 is the best of them, sharpness wise). Some prefer the earlier MC version for its smoother bokeh, but again, the MD lens is much easier to convert to EOS, so I only have experience with MD.
There are definitely many other gems in the Rokkor lineup, but as I'm using mine on Canon 5Dmk2, converting wide-angles with floating elements is a no-no. So there we go, with standard lenses and mid-teles. _________________ List of lenses |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
Lloydy
 Inscrit le: 02 Sep 2009 Messages: 7880 Localisation: Ironbridge. UK.
Expire: 2022-01-01
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 4:24 pm Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Jeu Avr 03, 2014 4:24 pm Sujet du message: |
|
|
Lloydy wrote:
28 / 3.5, I like a lot.
45 / 2, very good, but close to the 50's so I don't use it much.
50 / 1.4, just about my favorite lens
50 / 1.7, lovely lens, but I reach for the 1.4
100 / 2.5 Superb lens, I love everything about this lens.
100 / 3.5 Macro, it's a big heavy thing, but sharp - very sharp.
135 / 2.8 Another favorite,
135 / 3.5 Some say this is the sharper 135? maybe it is, it's another very good lens.
35-70 / 3.5 Macro, don't leave home without it
I got into Minolta's very late, I was always a Canon + Pentax man, I wish I'd discovered Minolta a long time ago.  _________________ LENSES & CAMERAS FOR SALE.....
I have loads of stuff that I have to get rid of, if you see me commenting about something I have got and you want one, ask me.
My Flickr https://www.flickr.com/photos/mudplugga/
My ipernity -
http://www.ipernity.com/home/294337 |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
dnas
 Inscrit le: 14 Nov 2008 Messages: 488 Localisation: Japan
|
 Posté: Ven Avr 04, 2014 12:03 am Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Ven Avr 04, 2014 12:03 am Sujet du message: |
|
|
dnas wrote:
Two lenses that I own, that stand out, even above the MC/MD Rokkor 50mm F1.4 lenses, and many other great Minolta MC & MC Rokkors:
Minolta MD 85mm F2
Minolta MD 100mm F4 Macro |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
Boris_Akunin
 Inscrit le: 22 Août 2013 Messages: 392 Localisation: Bremen, Germany
|
 Posté: Ven Avr 04, 2014 11:59 pm Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Ven Avr 04, 2014 11:59 pm Sujet du message: |
|
|
Boris_Akunin wrote:
As far as I could gather, these are the most interesting Minolta primes (my personal favourites are bolded):
-MC/MD 16mm f/2.8 Fisheye (both the 11/8 and the 10/7 version)
-MC/MD 17mm f/4
-MD 20mm f/2.8 (not as good as the MC21 but much smaller)
-MC 21mm f/2.8
-MC/MD 24mm f/2.8 (the 9/7 version, the late MD 8/8 version is worse but still quite good, the VFC version may be better)
-MC/MD 28mm f/2 (the 10/9 version, the late MD 9/9 version seems to be worse) EDIT: Actually it seems to be the other way around if the tests at artaphot.ch are to be believed!
-MC/MD 35mm f/1.8 (the MC and early MD version, the late MD version seems to be a bit worse)
-MC/MD 50mm f/1.4 (The MC "Rokkor-PG" version seems to be the best for Bokeh and wide open sharpness, the late MD version is slightly sharper when stopped down)
-MD 50mm f/1.2
-MC 58mm f/1.4
-MC 58mm f/1.2
-MC 85mm f/1.7
-MD 85mm f/2
-MD 100mm f/2.5 (the late, plain MD version)
-MC/MD 135mm f/2.8 (the 4/4 version)
-MD 135mm f/2
-MC/MD 200mm f/4 (the late MC and early MD version, the lighter and smaller late MD version is worse)
-MD 200mm f/2.8
Some are very rare and probably too expensive (16/2.8, 21/2.8, 135/2 ),
some are affordable though not cheap (24/2.8, 28/2, 35/1.8, 50/1.2, 58/1.2, 85/1.7, 85/2, 200/2.8 )
and some can often be had for great prices (50/1.4, 100/2.5, 135/2.8, 200/4 )
There are other, less 'special' lenses that are still quite good and often dirt cheap (i.e. 35/2.8, 50/1.7 )
The 28/2 and 35/1.8 make great normal lenses on APS-C, the 35/1.8 is a bit sharper but it's a matter of choice.
The f/1.2's (50 & 58 ) make great portrait lenses on APS-C, the 50/1.2 is probably the better choice as a general purpouse lens on FF cameras.
The 85/1.7 is a great portrait lens on FF cameras, on APS-C the 85/2 may be the better choice (sharper across the frame).
I have collected a few (24/2.8, 28/2, 35/1.8, 58/1.2, 100/2.5, 135/2.8, 200/4 and a 85/1.7 is on the way) and I am very satisfied with all of them.
If the money isn't too tight, I'd suggest looking for these:
21/2.8 or 24/2.8
28/2 or 35/1.8
50/1.2 or 58/1.2
85/2 or 85/1.7
135/2.8 or 135/2
200/4 or 200/2.8
For small budgets these are the ones to look for:
35/2.8 or 28/2.8
50/1.4 ("MC Rokkor-PG") or 50/1.7
100/2.5 (the 'plain MD' version)
135/2.8 (the 4/4 version)
200/4 (the heavier version)
Daniels list (http://minolta.eazypix.de/lenses/) helps with identifying the different versions.
You may be able to find the more expensive lenses at good prices, sometimes the sellers have no idea what they have...
(I paid 39€ for my 58/1,2 and 25€ for my 35/1.8)
regards
Jan
more sources:
http://artaphot.ch/minolta-sr/objektive
http://artaphot.ch/sony-nex/altglas _________________ Sony: A7 | Samyang FE 35/2.8 | Sony FE 85/1.8
Pentax: K-5 | K28/3.5 | M50/1.7 | DA18-135/3.5-5.6 | F35-70/3.5-4.5
Minolta: X-500 | XD | MD35/2.8 | MC50/1.4 | MD200/4 | MD75-150/4
Canon: nFD24/2.8 | nFD35/2 | nFD50/1.4 | nFD300/5.6 | nFD35-105/3.5
Dernière modification par Boris_Akunin le Mer Nov 12, 2014 5:46 am ; modifié 1 fois au total |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
Layer-cake
 Inscrit le: 18 Mar 2013 Messages: 560 Localisation: Cape Town
|
 Posté: Sam Avr 05, 2014 5:26 pm Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Sam Avr 05, 2014 5:26 pm Sujet du message: |
|
|
Layer-cake wrote:
with all the good words forinseil has put in about the MD 50mm F2 I managed to find one today for cheap and I have to admit it is a nice lens to use, I always discounted it due to its speed but it seems much nicer than than 1.7 I had:) |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
Boris_Akunin
 Inscrit le: 22 Août 2013 Messages: 392 Localisation: Bremen, Germany
|
 Posté: Sam Avr 05, 2014 10:41 pm Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Sam Avr 05, 2014 10:41 pm Sujet du message: |
|
|
Boris_Akunin wrote:
| Layer-cake a écrit: |
| with all the good words forinseil has put in about the MD 50mm F2 I managed to find one today for cheap and I have to admit it is a nice lens to use, I always discounted it due to its speed but it seems much nicer than than 1.7 I had:) |
They built that thing in large numbers and without the need for speed they could optimize the design for other goals.
| ForenSeil a écrit: |
| Minolta MD 50/2 - Pssssst... like the Minolta 135/2.8 often underrated but optically imho one of the very best manual 50ies around, best CA control ever, decent sharpness wide open and ultra sharp stopped down, finest Minolta colors, imho better than 50/1.4 and even a little better than the 50/1.7. I once made a direct comparision on NEX-5N between the MD 50/2, the MD 50/1.4, Hexanon 5X/1.4;5X/1.7;5X1.8, Carl Zeiss HFT Planar 50/1.8 and -believe it or not - the MD 50/2 was better @F2 than all other @F2 - the best is - it can be had for less than 20€. Only drawback ist that it's partiall made of plastic. |
I wonder how it compares to the MC "Rokkor-PG" 50/1.4 and the f/1.2's (or the Helios-44?). It sounds like a great choice for a compact kit or for an expendable one for hazardous circumstances.
Also, Rokkorfiles has a few interesting comparisons, I don't think these have been linked to yet.
MD50/1.2 vs MC58/1.2:
http://www.rokkorfiles.com/Battle%20of%2050s1.htm
MC "Rokkor-PG" 50/1.4 vs MC "Rokkor-X" 50/1.4:
http://www.rokkorfiles.com/Battle%20of%2050s2.htm
MC 85/1.7 vs MD 85/1.7 vs MD 85/2 vs 85/2.8 Varisoft:
http://www.rokkorfiles.com/85mm%20Page%201.htm
All their lens reviews:
http://www.rokkorfiles.com/Lens%20Reviews.html
Those comparisons are great if you can't decide between the f/1.2's or the 85's. (No, you can't have both. There are people who can help you with your addiction... )
I think this would be my final list of 6, like Mir asked for:
MC 21/2.8
MD 35/1.8 (the early MD version)
MC 58/1.2 (for APS-C, the MD 50/1.2 for FF)
MD 85/2 (for APS-C, the MC 85/1.7 for FF)
MD 135/2
MD 200/2.8 (and the MD 300-s 2x converter too, if it doesn't count as a 7th lens)
regards
Jan[url][/url]  _________________ Sony: A7 | Samyang FE 35/2.8 | Sony FE 85/1.8
Pentax: K-5 | K28/3.5 | M50/1.7 | DA18-135/3.5-5.6 | F35-70/3.5-4.5
Minolta: X-500 | XD | MD35/2.8 | MC50/1.4 | MD200/4 | MD75-150/4
Canon: nFD24/2.8 | nFD35/2 | nFD50/1.4 | nFD300/5.6 | nFD35-105/3.5
Dernière modification par Boris_Akunin le Sam Avr 05, 2014 11:00 pm ; modifié 1 fois au total |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
ForenSeil
 Inscrit le: 15 Avr 2011 Messages: 2731 Localisation: Kappeln, Schleswig-Holstein, Germany.
|
 Posté: Sam Avr 05, 2014 10:52 pm Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Sam Avr 05, 2014 10:52 pm Sujet du message: |
|
|
ForenSeil wrote:
| Boris_Akunin a écrit: |
| Layer-cake a écrit: |
| with all the good words forinseil has put in about the MD 50mm F2 I managed to find one today for cheap and I have to admit it is a nice lens to use, I always discounted it due to its speed but it seems much nicer than than 1.7 I had:) |
They built that thing in large numbers and without the need for speed they could optimize the design for other goals.
| ForenSeil a écrit: |
| Minolta MD 50/2 - Pssssst... like the Minolta 135/2.8 often underrated but optically imho one of the very best manual 50ies around, best CA control ever, decent sharpness wide open and ultra sharp stopped down, finest Minolta colors, imho better than 50/1.4 and even a little better than the 50/1.7. I once made a direct comparision on NEX-5N between the MD 50/2, the MD 50/1.4, Hexanon 5X/1.4;5X/1.7;5X1.8, Carl Zeiss HFT Planar 50/1.8 and -believe it or not - the MD 50/2 was better @F2 than all other @F2 - the best is - it can be had for less than 20€. Only drawback ist that it's partiall made of plastic. |
I wonder how it compares to the MC "Rokkor-PG" 50/1.4 and the f/1.2's (or the Helios-44?). It sounds like a great choice for a compact kit or for an expendable one for hazardous circumstances. |
I've also had it in this wide open comparision with Helios 44 and some others, here it was the winner aswell.
http://forum.mflenses.com/a-little-comparision-between-some-cheap-50mm-lenses-t45319,highlight,%2B50mm.html
It a secret Summicron-R 50/2 V1.5
I would expect that the F1.2's would have more vignetting @F2 and slightly lower contrast and that they should both on about the same level @F8; except that I would expect more barrel distortion on the F1.2's
But I have the slight suspection that MD 50/2 has either slightly worse quality control than their more expensive metal counterparts or that there are more than one... often I read mixed reviews about it, sometimes it's the "very best" like my test did show, sometimes slightly inferior to the 50/1.4 and 50/1.7, some people were even saying it's a "toss-away"....
EDIT: There are at least three versions of the Minolta 50/2, 1973 MC 50/2, 1977 MD and 1981 MD - should be the reason for hardly mixed opinions; I guess I'm refering to the latest one
Btw.: Between the second and the third 50/2 there was the MD 45/2 in production for a short time.
Here are some samples on film: http://forum.mflenses.com/viewtopic,p,1219748.html#1219748 _________________ I'm not a collector, I'm a tester
My camera: Sony A7+Zeiss Sonnar 55/1.8
Current favourite lenses (I have many more):
A few macro-Tominons, Samyang 12/2.8, Noritsu 50.7/9.5, Rodagon 105/5.6 on bellows, Samyang 135/2, Celestron C8 2000mm F10
Most wanted: Samyang 24/1.4, Laowa 100/2.8 2x, Nikon 200/2 ED
Dernière modification par ForenSeil le Mar Avr 08, 2014 2:02 am ; modifié 7 fois au total |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
Boris_Akunin
 Inscrit le: 22 Août 2013 Messages: 392 Localisation: Bremen, Germany
|
 Posté: Sam Avr 05, 2014 11:29 pm Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Sam Avr 05, 2014 11:29 pm Sujet du message: |
|
|
Boris_Akunin wrote:
Thanks, I think I need to grab one of those off ebay. It's a nice compact alternative to the 58 and I can sell off my 50/1.4.
I just found a great deal for a Fuji kit at a local dealer (X-E1 + 18-55 + 55-230* new for 750€), if I find a 50/2 I can post a direct comparison with the 58 if anyone's interested. I'll have to reduce my Minolta collection to the few best lenses anyway (those in my sig are just the primes) so I'll be making test shot with all of them.
*That one will be on sale the next day... _________________ Sony: A7 | Samyang FE 35/2.8 | Sony FE 85/1.8
Pentax: K-5 | K28/3.5 | M50/1.7 | DA18-135/3.5-5.6 | F35-70/3.5-4.5
Minolta: X-500 | XD | MD35/2.8 | MC50/1.4 | MD200/4 | MD75-150/4
Canon: nFD24/2.8 | nFD35/2 | nFD50/1.4 | nFD300/5.6 | nFD35-105/3.5
|
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
woodrim
 Inscrit le: 14 Jan 2010 Messages: 4069 Localisation: Charleston
|
 Posté: Dim Avr 06, 2014 12:06 am Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Dim Avr 06, 2014 12:06 am Sujet du message: |
|
|
woodrim wrote:
I don't understand the rational (or maybe just don't agree) of making wide open comparisons of different speed lenses. Certainly before I made a judgement between any of them, I'd want to know how they compared at the first common aperture. Is the f/2 better at f/2 than a 1.4 version is at f/2?
The link to the comparison of 1.4/50 MC and MD lenses seems to be splitting hairs. I can't imagine there being a perceivable difference in regular use. I'm more than happy with my 1.4/50 MC PG. I use it because I love it, and I love it when I use it. _________________ Regards,
Woodrim |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
ForenSeil
 Inscrit le: 15 Avr 2011 Messages: 2731 Localisation: Kappeln, Schleswig-Holstein, Germany.
|
 Posté: Dim Avr 06, 2014 12:20 am Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Dim Avr 06, 2014 12:20 am Sujet du message: |
|
|
ForenSeil wrote:
| woodrim a écrit: |
| I don't understand the rational (or maybe just don't agree) of making wide open comparisons of different speed lenses. Certainly before I made a judgement between any of them, I'd want to know how they compared at the first common aperture. Is the f/2 better at f/2 than a 1.4 version is at f/2? |
It gives a good idea about their character, that's why I've made it that way these days.
Also to make a comparision @F2.8 would be slightly unfair, as the Tessar and Industars were wide open there while others already stopped down for two full stops.
That would consequently lead to a comparision of all lenses at all stops from wide open to F16, which is too much efford for a quick test of so many cheap lenses
But I can asure you, that also @F2-only and @F2.8-only comparision that Minolta MD 50/2 would have been the winner aswell, and at F5.6 it would be hard to see differences in terms of sharpness from most of the competitors in that test setup.
PS:
The MC PG 50/1.4 has slightly better ratings than the MD 50/1.4 btw. but as you said the differences are rather small. _________________ I'm not a collector, I'm a tester
My camera: Sony A7+Zeiss Sonnar 55/1.8
Current favourite lenses (I have many more):
A few macro-Tominons, Samyang 12/2.8, Noritsu 50.7/9.5, Rodagon 105/5.6 on bellows, Samyang 135/2, Celestron C8 2000mm F10
Most wanted: Samyang 24/1.4, Laowa 100/2.8 2x, Nikon 200/2 ED
Dernière modification par ForenSeil le Lun Avr 07, 2014 7:27 pm ; modifié 4 fois au total |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
Boris_Akunin
 Inscrit le: 22 Août 2013 Messages: 392 Localisation: Bremen, Germany
|
 Posté: Dim Avr 06, 2014 12:40 am Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Dim Avr 06, 2014 12:40 am Sujet du message: |
|
|
Boris_Akunin wrote:
| woodrim a écrit: |
| The link to the comparison of 1.4/50 MC and MD lenses seems to be splitting hairs. I can't imagine there being a perceivable difference in regular use. I'm more than happy with my 1.4/50 MC PG. I use it because I love it, and I love it when I use it. |
The 50/1.4's have different optical formulas, those with 55mm filter thread are 7/5 (supposedly derived from the MC58/1.2), the 49mm versions are 7/6 (like the 50/1.2).
They are very close and sample variation may make more of a difference than the optical formula but they're not all the same.
The 7/5 "MC Rokkor-PG" version seems to have become a bit of a favourite.
I'd take the MC version just for it's smoother focus ring (brass on aluminium, Minolta switched to alu/alu to save weight)
Sauce:
http://minolta.eazypix.de/lenses/ _________________ Sony: A7 | Samyang FE 35/2.8 | Sony FE 85/1.8
Pentax: K-5 | K28/3.5 | M50/1.7 | DA18-135/3.5-5.6 | F35-70/3.5-4.5
Minolta: X-500 | XD | MD35/2.8 | MC50/1.4 | MD200/4 | MD75-150/4
Canon: nFD24/2.8 | nFD35/2 | nFD50/1.4 | nFD300/5.6 | nFD35-105/3.5
|
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
memetph
 Inscrit le: 01 Déc 2013 Messages: 940 Localisation: Poland
|
 Posté: Lun Avr 07, 2014 9:00 am Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Lun Avr 07, 2014 9:00 am Sujet du message: |
|
|
memetph wrote:
For those reading french , there is a site under the name of Suaudeau which shows some interesting comparisons.
There is an extensive one on Rokkors standard lenses.
Based on the information of this site, I bought the MC 50 1.4 FG and the MC 28 3.5 SG.
Dernière modification par memetph le Lun Avr 07, 2014 12:58 pm ; modifié 1 fois au total |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
LucisPictor
 Inscrit le: 26 Fév 2007 Messages: 17633 Localisation: Oberhessen, Germany / Maidstone ('95-'96)
Expire: 2013-12-03
|
 Posté: Lun Avr 07, 2014 10:51 am Sujet du message: |
|
 Posté: Lun Avr 07, 2014 10:51 am Sujet du message: |
|
|
LucisPictor wrote:
Definitely the Rokkor 2/28. _________________ Personal forum activity on pause every now and again (due to job obligations)!
Carsten, former Moderator
Things ON SALE
Carsten = "KAPCTEH" = "Karusutenu" | T-shirt?.........................My photos from Emilia: http://www.schouler.net/emilia/emilia2011.html
My gear: http://retrocameracs.wordpress.com/ausrustung/
Old list: http://forum.mflenses.com/viewtopic.php?t=65 (Not up-to-date, sorry!) | http://www.lucispictor.de | http://www.alensaweek.wordpress.com |
http://www.retrocamera.de |
|
| Haut de page |
|
 |
|
|