MFlenses - Une nouvelle vie à l’ère numérique
MFLenses 2026

Forum des objectifs à mise au point manuelle

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.
Pleins feux

Emplacement partenaire mis en avant sur la page d’accueil du forum.

Anybody knows the Minolta 100-500 f8?
Voir le sujet précédent :: Voir le sujet suivant  


Reply

Hi guys,

I'm searching for a long tele and there is a minolta Rokkor 100-500 f8 lens on ebay for smal money! I have an adapter and would use it on my D200.

The adapter is good quality and I like the pictures taken with the minolta 35-70 3.5 and 250 f5.6 mirror.

Now, does anybody knows anything about this lens? The interenet ist not very helpful this time!

cheers,

Karhallarn


Reply

In my limited knowledge, Rokkor lenses seem to be held in high regard. If it is truly little money then worth a shot?


Reply

martyn_bannister a écrit:
In my limited knowledge, Rokkor lenses seem to be held in high regard. If it is truly little money then worth a shot?


+1

I haven't tested it, but I haven't found a bad Rokkor lens yet. Smile
By the way, they weigh over 2000 grams. I had the chance to get one cheap and didn't. Wish I had.
For me that is a very usable focal length.


Reply

buy the membership for the gym along with that lens Wink i have maginon 100-500mm and last year i went on a walk with it on my oly and after a while my arms were soar like i worked out in a gym...

as for quality, it's a good bet that it's a good glass


Reply

martyn_bannister a écrit:
In my limited knowledge, Rokkor lenses seem to be held in high regard.


walter g a écrit:
I haven't tested it, but ...


WolverineX a écrit:
... as for quality, it's a good bet that it's a good glass


Everybody just guessing, but not much reliable informaton yet. That should change pretty soon Wink.

S


Reply

there is an Apo version of the same lens, but never seen one for reeal, gotta be the first apo zoom in vintage minolta


Reply

kiddo a écrit:
there is an Apo version of the same lens, but never seen one for reeal, gotta be the first apo zoom in vintage minolta


Yes, I know ... but first let's test the earlier non-APO MD 8/100-500mm Wink

BTW the first Minolta APO lens was the MC 5.6/400mm APO (1976), then came the Minolta MD 6.3/600mm APO (1978), and only then the Minolta MD 8/100-500mm APO (1983). Not much later we had the Minolta AF 2.8/300mm APO and AF 4/60mm APO (1985), and in 1987 came the first fast APO telezoom, the Minolta AF 2.8/80-200mm APO.

S


Reply

stevemark a écrit:
martyn_bannister a écrit:
In my limited knowledge, Rokkor lenses seem to be held in high regard.


walter g a écrit:
I haven't tested it, but ...


WolverineX a écrit:
... as for quality, it's a good bet that it's a good glass


Everybody just guessing, but not much reliable informaton yet. That should change pretty soon Wink.

S


It would be great I you could test it - i've got one sample of the MD Zoom Rokkor 100-500 mm f/8 but the weight and length of this beast kept me from obtaining any meaningful pictures out of it yet. What i've found out until now is that the lens still delivers quite useable images at the longest focal length, but that its slow speed wide open limits its potential for outdoor wildlife.




Reply

I've got the Tamron 200-500mm and I thought that's an unusable lens for it's weight, but my son has some fun with it on APSC , in fact the 80cm rokkor should weight about the same

Dernière modification par kiddo le Dim Jan 07, 2024 10:56 am ; modifié 2 fois au total


Reply

Alsatian2017 a écrit:
stevemark a écrit:
martyn_bannister a écrit:
In my limited knowledge, Rokkor lenses seem to be held in high regard.


walter g a écrit:
I haven't tested it, but ...


WolverineX a écrit:
... as for quality, it's a good bet that it's a good glass


Everybody just guessing, but not much reliable informaton yet. That should change pretty soon Wink.

S


It would be great I you could test it - i've got one sample of the MD Zoom Rokkor 100-500 mm f/8 but the weight and length of this beast kept me from obtaining any meaningful pictures out of it yet. What i've found out until now is that the lens still delivers quite useable images at the longest focal length, but that its slow speed wide open limits its potential for outdoor wildlife.




I have two; the plain MD and also the later MDIII APO. They were bought more out of curiosity to complete my collection rather than for practical use. I just got very lucky as both were offered with the matching close-up lens at a price I couldn't justify resisting at the time.

I actually found the Minolta achromatic 72mm close-up lenses that came with them to be more useful than the zoom lenses themselves, as they also go perfectly with the Minolta MD 135/2 and 200/2.8 lenses. This is partly why I bought those zooms as those close-up lenses by themselves go for stupid money; I don't think the sellers realised this...

The zooms haven't seen much use; they are large, heavy and slow, and as far as ergonomics go they they are awkward to say the least. The tripod mount isn't anywhere near the centre of gravity either and although I have a sturdy tripod, it really needs something even sturdier and at 500mm ideally an additional front support as well. Add to that the fact that I don't drive, so I haven't really used them much.

I would also be interested to see Stephan's test shots at some point.


Reply

Impossible to take meaningful "long range" shots today (snow / air turbulences), therefore an indoor trial from a distance of about 8m.

First the entire image, depicting a steel engraving by Schuler from around 1850. Lots of detail!




Minolta MD-III 8/500mm Reflex - 100% crop near the upper left corner:


Minolta MD-I 8/100-500mm @ 500mm f8:


Minolta MD-I 8/100-500mm @ 500mm f11 plus CAs removed:


That's pretty remarkable and much better than I would have expected.

BTW selling price in Germany 1979 around 1800 DM, the APO version 1984 more than 3000 DM ...

S


EDIT: I was pretty surprised how big the 8/100-500mm is, compared to the MD 4/70-210 or the MD 5.6/100-300mm. And now I really start to wonder how good the APO version would be ...


Reply

The Minolta 8/100-500mm is big - much bigger than I had expected! I really dwarfs the Miinolta MD 4.5/75-200mm, which is by no means a small lens:



No outdoor testing yet - it's still snowing here ...

S


Dernière modification par stevemark le Lun Nov 04, 2024 8:37 pm ; modifié 1 fois au total


Reply

stevemark a écrit:
The Minolta 8/100-500mm is big - much bigger than I had expected! I really dwarfs the Miinolta MD 4.5/75-200mm, which is by no means a small lens:



No outdoor testing yet - it's still snowing here ...

S


that´s a big wow, do you have the tamron 200-500mm to compare it with?
probably the apo would be the same except CA


Reply

kiddo a écrit:
... do you have the tamron 200-500mm to compare it with?

Yes.

kiddo a écrit:
probably the apo would be the same except CA

Yep. Almost exactly the same size and weight as the non-APO show above (well, 1.5mm longer and 20g lighter). And one doublet split in two single lenses to accomodate for the slightly different lens radii of the AD glass (or Fluorite?) lens.

S


Reply

stevemark a écrit:
The Minolta 8/100-500mm is big - much bigger than I had expected! I really dwarfs the Miinolta MD 4.5/75-200mm, which is by no means a small lens:



No outdoor testing yet - it's still snowing here ...

S


That's a good way to demonstrate the size of this lens; the usual brochure and internet images don't really do it justice.

It gets even worse once you add the 91mm long screw-in lens hood...