MFlenses - Une nouvelle vie à l’ère numérique
MFLenses 2026

Forum des objectifs à mise au point manuelle

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.
Pleins feux

Emplacement partenaire mis en avant sur la page d’accueil du forum.

What are your thoughts on this wide angle lens lens?
Voir le sujet précédent :: Voir le sujet suivant  


Reply

This is a wide angle lens made for full frame camera with with the following spec:

Focal length: 28mm to 35mm (inclusive)
Aperture: F2.0 to F2.5 (inclusive)
MFD: 30cm to 40cm (inclusive)

This is an interesting lens with some characters I have never seen. I got some interesting comments from one of my friends after I sent him the sample photos.

All the photos are taken with Sony A7RII. The images are sized to 50% of the original with the default Adobe Lightroom settings. It is best to download the photos and view it at 100%.

Any comments would be appreciated!

#1


#2


#3


#4


#5


#6


#7


#8


Reply

my initial findings looking at your pictures;

for my taste i dont find it very special.

i do have a feeling as some images are in a slight movement so it does resent the typical action of an old skool street photogaphy.
could be the lens also rendering like that.
so this could be seen as a special character and be used for that purpose

it's clear to me that images are made with digital camera and a 'less quality lens'.

it looks somewhat soft, but with the details = soft & soft micro contrast?

strange to me is that direct light source picture. very much without flare and minimal ghosting. modern or old ..?

with a different white-balance setup or a bit of PP could mimic analogue photography.
could also look good in black-white with added noise / grain, .. maybe.

something reminds me on pentacon 29, checked other images .. no its not.
you have mentioned few days back, your lens collection from between '30-'60, uncoated.
In that case i cant comment much

to close it down, im not sure if i like it.
it has some potential but then i should use it my self to try it out and be sure bout that.


Reply

Cosina?


Reply

I'd guess it is closer to 35 than 28mm. A bit bloomy in the night shots, can't really tell if it is decentered or not in these pics


Reply

This lens is coated. All the photo are taken at wide open or slightly stop down. Here is one more photo focused at about 2 to 3 meter.



@alex_d
You have a pair of well-trained eyes on identifying MFlenses. If you have time to visit Hong Kong, make sure you send me a pm. Wink

@caspert79
I don't think it is made by Cosina.

@D1N0
Yes. It is more close to 35mm.

I don't think the lens is decentered. Check out the extra photo below. The photo is deliberately overexposed to keep the shadows visible.



Reply

second thoughts

well controlled flare & ghosting so that's mostly for modern lenses.

also the texture (render) of the image is more modern-ish than vintage-ish.
OOF is very smooth and with clear boheh balls.
from what i have seen, if is some of those '30-'60 lenses, OOF would be different, much more bussy.
There are some pics here of DKL lenses and i take that as a reference for this case.

could it be some samyang-ish or a modern better chinese-ish

however, this 'movement' what i wrote about and d1no mentioned as decentred - for me it's the character that it makes confusing here.

but also on the last pic, purple ca is to me very characteristic type for a modern lens.
it's an interessting quiz. you did it before me as i was planning something but still no time.

one more take on a vintage-ish, a decentred lydith 30?

thanx for the invitation to HK!


Reply

My first thought was that these snapshots are far too "wild" and chaotic to show the potential of any lens (unless it would be a "perfect" lens such as th Zeiss Otus 1.4/28mm). The images have an extreme contrast, they probably were shot with high ISO, there's movement, and the colors don't look nice (NOT a fault of the lens - I am simply talking about the crude artificial light). All this makes it dfficult for me to clearly see the advantages and disadvantages of this particular lens.

Two aspects are obvious:

1) very little ghosting => excellent coating and/or very well caclulated lens surfaces are reducing flare to a really low amount => really good contrast
2) general correction of the lens is "not excellent" ("average") - probably comparable to other well known 2/35mm vintage lenses (difficult to judge for me since I never use vintage lenses wide open when shooting comparable images)

That said, I would use this lens in a different way:
1) stopping down to reduce the evident aberrations when shooting night time cityscapes
2) using it wide open either in b/w mode (=> "glow") or e. g. for low contrast sceneries such as portraits

I assume a modern construction which deliberately was adjusted for "character".

S


Reply

alex_d a écrit:

could it be some samyang-ish or a modern better chinese-ish

Since it has F number between F2 to F2.5, it can’t be a pentacon 29 or meyer 30. From what I heard, this lens a modern better chinese-ish.

alex_d a écrit:

it's an interessting quiz. you did it before me as i was planning something but still no time.

Good to hear you found it is interesting. My aim is to gather opinions rather than letting you guys know which lens is it.


stevemark a écrit:
My first thought was that these snapshots are far too "wild" and chaotic to show the potential of any lens (unless it would be a "perfect" lens such as th Zeiss Otus 1.4/28mm). The images have an extreme contrast, they probably were shot with high ISO, there's movement, and the colors don't look nice (NOT a fault of the lens - I am simply talking about the crude artificial light). All this makes it dfficult for me to clearly see the advantages and disadvantages of this particular lens.

True. Not many lenses can do well in my extreme test. It is not a perfect lens by any means. I would say the color of this lens is relatively neutral.

Here is a photo with normal contrast scene. I don’t stop the lens down as I want to show its character. Stopping it down will improve the contrast and resolution but it will never reach the level of the more perfect lenses.


stevemark a écrit:

That said, I would use this lens in a different way:
1) stopping down to reduce the evident aberrations when shooting night time cityscapes
2) using it wide open either in b/w mode (=> "glow") or e. g. for low contrast sceneries such as portraits

Both are viable ways to use this lens! I think stopping down one stop will be fine for shooting night time cityscapes unless with a tripod.

stevemark a écrit:

I assume a modern construction which deliberately was adjusted for "character".

You are right. This lens is designed for "character". Stopping it will make its character less obvious.


Reply

Maybe the Iberit 35mm F2.4


Reply

D1N0 a écrit:
Maybe the Iberit 35mm F2.4

Some of the characters of the Iberit 35mm F2.4 are quiet close to this lens. However, this lens has higher resolution than the Iberit, especially in the center.

Here is a photo converted to B&W. It look better?


Reply

An interesting one, I am not sure..


Reply

im not sure i understood that the spec charater is/was adjusted,
by the factory or after the purchase ?

i cant comment further as i dont have any of such lenses on my own, i quess im the weekest link ..


Reply

I found it reacts pretty well to monochrome, it gets rid of all the distracting colour in those city scapes



Reply

eggplant a écrit:
An interesting one, I am not sure..

Wink

alex_d a écrit:
im not sure i understood that the spec charater is/was adjusted,
by the factory or after the purchase ?

i cant comment further as i dont have any of such lenses on my own, i quess im the weekest link ..

No modification is made to the lens. I am sure this lens is a good copy.

I don't think it is your weakest link: you have made a good summary of the characters.

D1N0 a écrit:
I found it reacts pretty well to monochrome, it gets rid of all the distracting colour in those city scapes

Well done! B&W rocks!



Reply

yes BW is a diff story, as i wondered previously

im gonna high-jack this post for a moment as i see now that there is some knowledge here,

what is that, that makes modern samyang and some of better Chinese lenses having (for me at least) a recognisable texture of images?

i would say it's a specific kind of glass or is way/material of coating glass? i dont see an other option as an optical formula is different for each of them.

any takes on this for a moment ?



and, silly me, didnt noticed or havent read good this "Aperture: F2.0 to F2.5 (inclusive) "


Reply

The behaviour of the bokeh balls along the edges and in the corners of photo #8 seems unusual.

The oval shape of the bokeh balls sets in relatively close to the centre of the image, and they never go clearly cat-eye-shaped towards the edges/corners of the frame.

This seems to suggest that vignetting is not caused by intrusion of the edge of the rear element, which suggests a rather large rear element, yet not an image-telecentric design.

Also, to my eyes little distortion for a fast wide-angle.

More symmetrical non-retrofocus design with relatively large rear element maybe?


Reply

Is that extreme coma along the right side in #3, or is it the actual shape of the lights? It appears your model in #6 didn't approve of your lens choice. Wink

Is the glass hazy, scratched, fungused, or damaged in any way?


Reply

Calvin

You take excellent pics and have some excellent gear. This lens isnt one of them. A distinct lack of sharpness and contrast imho. I would guess a no name 28.

Thanks for the fun.


Reply

While I understand the desire for unbiased opinions, I think it is time to unravel the mystery? I like the rendering in any case, if it is a bright lens at maximum aperture

My bet: Cooke SP3 32mm 2.4


Reply

Crazy Leica Fox a écrit:

Is the glass hazy, scratched, fungused, or damaged in any way?


Certainly not - we have a very good contrast and almost completely missing ghosting/flares in spite of many strong light sources being directly within the images.
However you are right that the lens isn't particularly well corrected.

The combination of these two properties results in a somehow unusual characteristic of the lens.

S


Reply

I am sorry that I can't disclose the name of the lens right now as I promised the owner not to do so. I do take few more photos with stopping down the aperture before returning this lens to the owner today. I will post it shortly after I finish my dinner.


Reply

While these test shots are limited for my way of judging I must say it looks quite nice in its rendering.

It's funny that Ultrapix said Speed Panchro, I was thinking the same but it could be a similar cine lens.


Reply

alex_d a écrit:

what is that, that makes modern samyang and some of better Chinese lenses having (for me at least) a recognisable texture of images?

i would say it's a specific kind of glass or is way/material of coating glass? i dont see an other option as an optical formula is different for each of them.

any takes on this for a moment ?

I can't answer all but from my experience, the coating used by Chinese manufacture can be pretty good in my opinion. Some lower cost glass of high refractive index will have less transmission in violet/blue color compare to those higher cost glass.

RokkorDoctor a écrit:
The behaviour of the bokeh balls along the edges and in the corners of photo #8 seems unusual.

The oval shape of the bokeh balls sets in relatively close to the centre of the image, and they never go clearly cat-eye-shaped towards the edges/corners of the frame.

This seems to suggest that vignetting is not caused by intrusion of the edge of the rear element, which suggests a rather large rear element, yet not an image-telecentric design.

Also, to my eyes little distortion for a fast wide-angle.

More symmetrical non-retrofocus design with relatively large rear element maybe?

You have well-trained eyes! I don't know the design of this lens as this information is not avalible to me but the rear element does look large for me.

Ultrapix a écrit:
While I understand the desire for unbiased opinions, I think it is time to unravel the mystery? I like the rendering in any case, if it is a bright lens at maximum aperture

My bet: Cooke SP3 32mm 2.4


blotafton a écrit:
While these test shots are limited for my way of judging I must say it looks quite nice in its rendering.

It's funny that Ultrapix said Speed Panchro, I was thinking the same but it could be a similar cine lens.


Yes. Cine lens is the right direction.

stevemark a écrit:
Crazy Leica Fox a écrit:

Is the glass hazy, scratched, fungused, or damaged in any way?


Certainly not - we have a very good contrast and almost completely missing ghosting/flares in spite of many strong light sources being directly within the images.
However you are right that the lens isn't particularly well corrected.

The combination of these two properties results in a somehow unusual characteristic of the lens.

S

Yes. I agree this lens is unusual. The first of its kind I have tried.


Reply

Is this a prototype? Smile


Reply

visualopsins a écrit:
Is this a prototype? Smile


No. That one will come later.

=========================================

Here are two set of photo take at wide open and stopped down 1.5 stop. I use custom white balance to keep the result consistent.

1. wide open


1. stopped down 1.5 stop


2. wide open


3. stopped down 1.5 stop


Honestly, I don't see there is significant improvement in the corners. So, there is no need to stop it down further. Wink