MFlenses - Une nouvelle vie à l’ère numérique
MFLenses 2026

Forum des objectifs à mise au point manuelle

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.

Explorez le monde des objectifs anciens à travers des notes de réparation, des photos d’essai réelles et des archives détaillées.
Pleins feux

Emplacement partenaire mis en avant sur la page d’accueil du forum.

New Nikon user here :)
Voir le sujet précédent :: Voir le sujet suivant  


Reply

Hi, I am new to manual focus photography. I just won an auction of some Sears M42 lenses. Now the problem is to get them to work on my D40. I done some research and it seems that Nikon F mount is the worse out of all for MF lenses. It doesn't go infinity without lens element adapter, which will lead to some amount of IQ degrade. Also no metering for lower end models such as mine. I have plans about upgrading soon, but I would really like to stay with Nikon since their offering of AF lenses suits my need the most. I am also considering Canon (500D?) and Pentax but they don't seems to offer good 18-2xx zoom, which is what I am planning to get soon.

Could you give me some advice on how to get the most out of M42 lenses with F mount Nikon?

I live in US, B&H used to offer a Bower glass adapter few weeks ago, now it's no longer available Sad


Reply

My opinion is that you should first get a cheap M42 film camera and see if you enjoy your new lenses.

If you do, and if you plan to get more, then I think the wiser solution is to invest in a Canon, Olympus, or Pentax digital SLR. There are models now that are very affordable even new. For instance a Canon 1000D should be around the 500 Euros. And if you look for used cameras, you can manage to get for instance a 400D for around 300 Euros.

This would be a relatively small investment that will let you enjoy a lot of manual focus lenses on digital. Of course you will keep your Nikon setup for autofocus use.


Reply

There are in fact Nikon/M42 adapters available with an added lens that will permit focusing to infinity. I am of the school that feels the degradation is not worth it, but others have been more fortunate than I. Personally, I used a very cheap Oly 300 digital for a while to see how I felt about the new world of manual lenses (including M42) - I own D70 and D200 nikons. I was sufficiently intrigued and impressed to invest in a Canon 40D which I now use for my non-nikkor lenses. Smile Smile


patrickh


Reply

The Bower adapter has been recommended by at least one member of this forum. I have had good results with an adapter made by "Kood". Some information is given here...

http://forum.mflenses.com/jupiter-37a-first-outing-t9430.html

The link compares the results obtained using (i) a Kood glass adapter and (ii) a simple mechanical adapter, for the mounting of a Jupiter 37a 3.5/135 on a Nikon D40x. Of course it was only possible to carry out the comparison for close subjects. Nevertheess the results are encouranging. I have had similar results with different M42 lenses with focal lengths ranging from 37 mm to 200 mm.


Reply

I have a M42 adapter for Nikon cameras and I think it's not worth to consider one.
Nikon has a great catalogue of lenses, also used.
Let's make an example. The Flektogon 20mms (M42) are great lenses, amongst the best in the 20mm range. But Nikon also has 20mm lenses that work great, for instance, I have a great performer, the Nikkor 3.5/20mm, which comes close to the results of the Flektogons. The Flek has perhaps a little advantage, but what happens when you attach an optical adapter to it? The optical quality degrades, and becomes much inferior to that of the Nikkor.
So where's the point?
Just buy a Nikkor 3.5/20mm, which is about the same price as the Flek, and live happy.
Or, if you absolutely want to use the Flek, buy a camera that allows to use it naturally.
These are the only two options that make sense in my opinion.


Reply

If people are buying a second DSLR body just for old MF lenses, then I think it's best to go for an Olympus.
With the short registration distance, you can use just about any lens, including a host of Minolta Rokkor (MC & MD) lenses, and Konica Hexnon lenses with a slight modification.

And I use Nikon & Olympus as well.

(but not Canon FL & FD lenses, of course)


Reply

But Oly has the 2x disadvantage, which I could not get used to.


patrickh


Reply

Orio a écrit:
... Canon 1000D should be around the 500 Euros. And if you look for used cameras, you can manage to get for instance a 400D for around 300 Euros.

This would be a relatively small investment that will let you enjoy a lot of manual focus lenses on digital.


For some people the sum of 500 Euros, or even 300 Euros, does not represent a relatively small investment. For myself it represents a relatively large one. Given my own circumstances, buying a camera dedicated to M42 lenses alone might be viewed as an extravagance. However for the relatively small (for me !) sum of 30 GBP I can buy an adapter and enjoy M42 lenses on a Nikon camera.

Note that it is not only impoverished members of the forum who have found "glass" adapters to be useful.....

http://www.flickr.com/groups/m42_lenses_and_dslrs/discuss/72157607341572099/

Vilhelm Sjostrom (aka Essox Lucius on this forum) says, of the Bower M42-Nikon adapter, "I've been very satisfied".


Reply

sichko a écrit:

Note that it is not only impoverished members of the forum who have found "glass" adapters to be useful.....
http://www.flickr.com/groups/m42_lenses_and_dslrs/discuss/72157607341572099/
Vilhelm Sjostrom (aka Essox Lucius on this forum) says, of the Bower M42-Nikon adapter, "I've been very satisfied".


Well, John, of course everyone is entitled to their own opinions. The sure fact is that with any optical adapter the image quality is always degraded to some extent, and this is an information that is correct to give to those who are not informed. The opinable part is how much the quality loss is acceptable or not for an user. There are certainly people who are not much concerned about losing some image quality, others instead are. So it really depends on how our friend here feels about it.

Speaking of money and budget, I still think that it makes not much sense to buy, for instance, a Flektogon 2.4/35 for 120 Euros and use it with an optical adapter, when with 80 Euros you can buy a Nikkor-O 2/35 like this one Cliquez ici pour voir sur Ebay that has the same excellent image quality as the Flektogon, is even a little faster, and can be used natively on Nikkor cameras with no quality loss.

But then, everyone is free to make their own evaluations!
-


Reply

Is the glass used in the better examples of these adapters enough to significantly degrade the image quality?

I know adding extra glass does degrade IQ, but I add good quality UV filters to my more expensive lenses and these make no noticeable difference that I've ever seen.

Just how thick is the glass in question?


Reply

What I find acceptable loss of quality someone else might find unacceptable. I've used M42 a lot without glass adapter as well, and comparing mechanical (no infinity) adapters with glass (infinity) adapters shows there is what I find acceptable loss of detail and contrast. Smaller sensors are likely more forgiving than the D3 sensor I am using, the better the sensor, the more it reveals defects in optical performance.

My exploration into M42 lenses on Nikon has been purely out of the nice 3D feel and (subjectively) pleasing out of focus rendering some of these lenses have. Much nicer way of painting the images than with modern aspherical designs, though sharpness is not au par with modern lens designs.

I think that there exists great variation in machining of these adapters: some are very good, some below quality control. But that applies to many M42 lenses I've tried as well. I would be careful to generalize as there are apples, oranges and lemons out there.

This is a compressed a 100% crop, Biotar 58/2 at near focusing limit, wide open with Bower glass adapter = as harsh "misuse" of the lens as possible, depth of field covers barely the hole in the leaf.



You can find more uploaded in original size by clicking below for my Flickr set

http://www.flickr.com/photos/mureena/sets/72157607140210153/


Reply

martinsmith99 a écrit:
Is the glass used in the better examples of these adapters enough to significantly degrade the image quality?
I know adding extra glass does degrade IQ, but I add good quality UV filters to my more expensive lenses and these make no noticeable difference that I've ever seen.
Just how thick is the glass in question?


Martin, the glass of a protection filter is just a screen, it has only one requirement, it needs to be invisible.
The glass of an optical adapter needs to change the focal point of a lens. in order to do this with just one glass element, it needs to act as a magnifying glass, it has no other way to do the task. If you look in a magnifying glass, you can see obvious distortion at the edges, and focus not constant from the centre to the edges. Of course the glass in the adapter is built with much more care than a simple magnifying glass, and yet, it works in the same way, so there is nothing to do about it, it does degrade the image quality. The only variable is how much degradation. Some adapters will degrade more, some less, but all of them will degrade to some extent.

BTW thickness of the glass is not the degrading factor (inside the lenses there are some very thick glasses). Shape is the degrading factor. And the quality of the optical glass used, of course. And the manufacturing. But while quality of glass used and manufacturing are improveable factors, the shape is not.


Reply

Thanks for all the feedbacks. I think I will get an adapter to try out the lenses before I put bigger money on a dedicated body.

Where can I find Bower adapter in the states? Also I notice some of you uses non glass element adapter, what exactly is the disadvantage of it? I don't quite get how can it focus at all without the correct length between the glass and sensor.


Reply

The lens will not focus to infinity, but depending on focal length it will focus relatively close. A 135 might reach to 10-20 feet for example. This is fine if you want to do macro work - especially with bellows or tubes ore even reversed.


patrickh


Reply

exe163 a écrit:
Where can I find Bower adapter in the states? Also I notice some of you uses non glass element adapter, what exactly is the disadvantage of it? I don't quite get how can it focus at all without the correct length between the glass and sensor.


http://www.bhphotovideo.com sells the Bower infinity adapter M42 to Nikon.

The main disadvantage of using a mechanical (non-glass) adapter is that with M42 lenses I cannot focus to infinity. Teles are more useful than shorter focal lengths.


Reply

Thanks I think I am going to get a non glass one and see what happens. B&H no longer sells the Bower adapter (seen it few weeks ago for ~40).


Reply

Grab the Kood adapter with glass from http://www.speedgraphic.co.uk/, it is better than Bower.


Reply

The following are all 100% crops of exposures shot with a Nikon D3, a Tessar 50/2.8 T and the Bower (glass) infinity adapter. 1st stage post-processing ie normal RAW to JPEG conversion. No curves, contrast or other adjustments applied. Sharpening set to 4/9 in RAW file. Distance to point of focus is 100 to 200 meters, you can see location in Flickr geotags.

about 200m to target


about 150m to target


about 100m to target


I find the loss of sharpness very acceptable, given that this lens was manufactured about 60 years before the sensor AND the fact that I'm placing a magnifying glass between the rear element and the sensor...

For original size files, please go here: http://www.flickr.com/photos/mureena/sets/72157607627290988/

About the lens: This is a pre-war design but post-war manufactured Tessar 50mm f/2.8 T with 12 bladed diaphragm. Plenty of bubbles (I count 9) and faint cleaning marks on the front coating.


Dernière modification par Esox lucius le Sam Mar 28, 2009 9:11 am ; modifié 3 fois au total


Reply

That's not bad at all, in fact it's quite acceptable. The cheapy glass adapters were what gave them all a bad name.


Reply

I ordered a non glass generic adapter that should come very soon. The Bowler one cost $35 + shipping at B&H, which cost half the amount I payed for 3 Sears lenses I have (and only), I worry I might get a bad sample and end up wasting a lot of money for no good reason. I will try out non glass adapter first and see if it fits my need.

I heard about reverse mount and transform a lens into Macro lens, how is this possible and is it possible on a Nikon body?

Thanks!